On Wednesday, Philip Gourevitch (author of We wish to inform you… see previous post) gave a reading and a Q & A on Pitt’s campus. He discussed the typical writing and researching—and then he got into politics. He’s incredibly opinionated and amazingly knowledgeable. I wish he announced the nightly international news (then it might actually be international!). Since I had already been thinking about Darfur and intervention, etc, as I listened to him talk, I applied some of it to what I know about Darfur.
Intervention is a funny thing—it appears simple and never, ever is. To go in for purely humanitarian reasons is a rare thing. It would be a nice thing, but it rarely happens because intervention cannot be separated from politics. Whenever two or more countries are involved, there is always a political aspect. (Whenever just one country is involved, there are always politics!)
Gourevitch made this connection clear. There are always politics. AND, if one or more countries are not going in with the best interest of the people affected in the country, they simply shouldn’t go. It’s not fair to the people affected to use them for political reasons.
At the same time that I’ve been reading and listening to Gourevitch, I’ve been studying the Twelve Year War in El Salvador. (1980-1992) In the late years of the Cold War, U.S. involvement in El Salvador was disturbingly political and allowed for major violations of human rights. (See The Massacre at El Mozote by Mark Danner for more info.)
In addition to learning about the histories of Rwanda and El Salvador, I’ve been learning and teaching Modern Latin American history as a teaching assistant. The professor of the course requires the students to write “State of the Nation” essays at major time points in Latin American history. These essays are to analyze the political, economic, and social patterns of the country, and a good essay (I tell them) describes the overall relationships between these three patterns.
The political, economic, and social aspects of a country cannot be separated. In El Salvador, the political turmoil opened the door for major social atrocities. In Rwanda, the three are so intertwined I would need three pages for the thesis statement alone (so see Gourevitch’s book, because he’s already described it). And in Darfur…
This is what I know: these matters are so complex that they cannot be taken lightly. The more I learn, the more I learn that I will never learn it all. There will always be more.
I have no answers. But a step toward seeking to understand the complexity seems to be a step in the right direction.
I think, by the way, that this is one of the reasons why I love writing: I’m learning history and politics (and even some economics!)—all in an MFA program for writing. Go figure. Writers have such opportunities to be interdisciplinary that it’s overwhelming. Thanks go to Gourevitch and various professors for opening these doors for me…
February 29, 2008
February 27, 2008
Genocide: Words have power.
Anyone who reads this blog regularly knows that I am reading over 20 books on violence this semester. Here’s the latest installment on my thoughts.
Last week, I gave a presentation on genocide. C—my project partner—and I led a class discussion on the book We wish to inform you that tomorrow we will be killed with our families by Philip Gourevitch. We wish is about the 1994 Rwandan genocide. And, if that wasn’t gloomy enough, we connected the Rwandan situation to Darfur.
Other than the time frame, the situations in Rwanda and Darfur appear similar: people are dying in Africa. Under the surface, however, the situations are very different. When C asked a refugee from Darfur about the similarities, the man looked at us quizzically. He said, “They are not the same. The conflict in Rwanda was tribal. The conflict in Darfur is religious.” But then he followed it up with, “Well, there are some similarities. In both cases, people die. Both are major genocides of the 21st century.”
A friend of mine currently in Darfur wrote, “Rwanda was clearly a genocide (even those who denied it while it was happening knew they were lying) but Darfur […is] a bit more questionable. They […] share a racial dynamic to them that is fascinating (and terrible) to look at, but I would warn against any type of broad brush strokes between the[m].” Darfur is NOT genocide? Wait… then what exactly is genocide?
If the difference between Rwanda in 1994 and the current situation in Darfur lies in the word “genocide,” then the similarity is there, too. (That’s weird logic, but hang with me.)
The word “genocide” was coined by a man named Raphael Lemkin, who was a Polish Jew in Europe before World War II. In the aftermath of a genocide in Armenia during WWI, he became fascinated with mass slaughter (as it was called before “genocide”), and began studying law to find a way to stop it. He identified Hitler’s rise to power as problematic, but no one listened to him. As a Jew, in 1939, he was forced to flee Europe.
Lemkin fled to the United States, where he continued his campaign to end mass slaughter, urging the international community to come together in order to stop such events from ever happening again. At some point, he realized that the crime needed a name. In addition to law education, Lemkin also had had linguistic training, and understood the importance of words. He named the crime “genocide,” which is Greek, “geno,” for race, Latin, “cide,” for kill. He published a book with the word, and continued to lobby to for laws to recognize genocide as a crime against humanity. (For more, check out Samantha Power’s book, “A Problem from Hell.”)
In 1946, a year after WWII ended, the United Nations recognized the concept of genocide. And in 1948, the Genocide Convention wrote the following definition:
“genocide means any of the following acts committed with intent to destroy, in whole or in part, a national, ethnical, racial or religious group, as such: (a) Killing members of the group; (b) Causing serious bodily or mental harm to members of the group; (c) Deliberately inflicting on the group conditions of life calculated to bring about its physical destruction in whole or in part; (d) Imposing measures intended to prevent births within the group; (e) Forcibly transferring children of the group to another group.” (genocidewatch.org)
After the document written by the 1948 Genocide Convention was ratified, genocide was recognized as an international crime. Once a crisis has been recognized as genocide, the international community then has an obligation to stop it.
According to www.genocidewatch.org, there are eight stages in genocide:
1. Classification
2. Symbolization
3. Dehumanization
4. Organization
5. Polarization
6. Preparation
7. Extermination
8. Denial
(I like genocidewatch.org’s definitions for these eight stages because it also outlines possible ways of preventing genocide at each stage.)
Back to Rwanda and Darfur:
Rwanda’s genocide followed each of these stages in a linear fashion. The Hutus and the Tutsis used language to divide and “Other.” The genocide occurred. And now, in some areas, it is being denied. In his book, Gourevitch points out a unique aspect of the Rwandan genocide: in no other genocide were the two sides ever expected to live side-by-side in the same country after the genocide.
Darfur’s genocide has not followed each of these stages in a linear fashion, and perhaps this is one of the reasons why international policies have been slow to respond. In the beginning, maybe it was fundamentally a religious problem. Sudan’s civil war was predominantly between the North and the South, Islamic and Christian regions, respectively. In the western province of Darfur, far removed from the civil war, the different tribes felt the effects of the civil war, which increased pre-existing tensions between groups there. The violence began when people in Darfur tried making their voice heard via violence, and the Janjaweed retaliated with more violence.
Darfur was not initially genocide when it began. It has since become genocide. Whole villages are being destroyed past the point of being inhabitable again. People are dying. Children are disappearing. It fits the definition. For more information, check out what Eric Reeves writes.
It all feels very far away from where I sit at my desk in Pittsburgh. And yet, I know it’s happening. There are people who have seen it who confirm it. There are articles appearing in the news with short sentences about it. Short sentences. Words.
I have known about what’s going on in Darfur for several years now. I've had friends working in Darfur as aid workers for those years. But somehow, the impact didn’t hit me until recently, when I tried studying to understand what’s going on there. I still don’t understand. I don’t think I ever fully will. But comprehension is dawning.
No longer are the short sentences I see hidden in the daily headlines simply words. There are meanings attached to these words. Genocide. The press throws it around so easily, not realizing it’s a bowling ball in a ping-pong game.
A final thought.
During the Rwandan genocide, the Red Cross was present in the country, which is traditionally a neutral organization. One aid member said that to be aware of the genocide and to do nothing about it was to contribute to the genocide, and he couldn’t do that anymore. So he spoke.
“In such circumstances, if you don’t speak out clearly, you are participating in the genocide. If you just shut up when you see what you see, and morally, ethically, you cannot shut up. It’s a responsibility to talk, to speak up.” (video)
So I blog. I’m not sure what can be said. What can be done. I have no on the ground answers. I know the pat answers here: pray, write to your congressman, go to awareness events, etc. But I feel very helpless.
In the circles of government, it’s a linguistic battle.
Words have power.
Last week, I gave a presentation on genocide. C—my project partner—and I led a class discussion on the book We wish to inform you that tomorrow we will be killed with our families by Philip Gourevitch. We wish is about the 1994 Rwandan genocide. And, if that wasn’t gloomy enough, we connected the Rwandan situation to Darfur.
Other than the time frame, the situations in Rwanda and Darfur appear similar: people are dying in Africa. Under the surface, however, the situations are very different. When C asked a refugee from Darfur about the similarities, the man looked at us quizzically. He said, “They are not the same. The conflict in Rwanda was tribal. The conflict in Darfur is religious.” But then he followed it up with, “Well, there are some similarities. In both cases, people die. Both are major genocides of the 21st century.”
A friend of mine currently in Darfur wrote, “Rwanda was clearly a genocide (even those who denied it while it was happening knew they were lying) but Darfur […is] a bit more questionable. They […] share a racial dynamic to them that is fascinating (and terrible) to look at, but I would warn against any type of broad brush strokes between the[m].” Darfur is NOT genocide? Wait… then what exactly is genocide?
If the difference between Rwanda in 1994 and the current situation in Darfur lies in the word “genocide,” then the similarity is there, too. (That’s weird logic, but hang with me.)
The word “genocide” was coined by a man named Raphael Lemkin, who was a Polish Jew in Europe before World War II. In the aftermath of a genocide in Armenia during WWI, he became fascinated with mass slaughter (as it was called before “genocide”), and began studying law to find a way to stop it. He identified Hitler’s rise to power as problematic, but no one listened to him. As a Jew, in 1939, he was forced to flee Europe.
Lemkin fled to the United States, where he continued his campaign to end mass slaughter, urging the international community to come together in order to stop such events from ever happening again. At some point, he realized that the crime needed a name. In addition to law education, Lemkin also had had linguistic training, and understood the importance of words. He named the crime “genocide,” which is Greek, “geno,” for race, Latin, “cide,” for kill. He published a book with the word, and continued to lobby to for laws to recognize genocide as a crime against humanity. (For more, check out Samantha Power’s book, “A Problem from Hell.”)
In 1946, a year after WWII ended, the United Nations recognized the concept of genocide. And in 1948, the Genocide Convention wrote the following definition:
“genocide means any of the following acts committed with intent to destroy, in whole or in part, a national, ethnical, racial or religious group, as such: (a) Killing members of the group; (b) Causing serious bodily or mental harm to members of the group; (c) Deliberately inflicting on the group conditions of life calculated to bring about its physical destruction in whole or in part; (d) Imposing measures intended to prevent births within the group; (e) Forcibly transferring children of the group to another group.” (genocidewatch.org)
After the document written by the 1948 Genocide Convention was ratified, genocide was recognized as an international crime. Once a crisis has been recognized as genocide, the international community then has an obligation to stop it.
According to www.genocidewatch.org, there are eight stages in genocide:
1. Classification
2. Symbolization
3. Dehumanization
4. Organization
5. Polarization
6. Preparation
7. Extermination
8. Denial
(I like genocidewatch.org’s definitions for these eight stages because it also outlines possible ways of preventing genocide at each stage.)
Back to Rwanda and Darfur:
Rwanda’s genocide followed each of these stages in a linear fashion. The Hutus and the Tutsis used language to divide and “Other.” The genocide occurred. And now, in some areas, it is being denied. In his book, Gourevitch points out a unique aspect of the Rwandan genocide: in no other genocide were the two sides ever expected to live side-by-side in the same country after the genocide.
Darfur’s genocide has not followed each of these stages in a linear fashion, and perhaps this is one of the reasons why international policies have been slow to respond. In the beginning, maybe it was fundamentally a religious problem. Sudan’s civil war was predominantly between the North and the South, Islamic and Christian regions, respectively. In the western province of Darfur, far removed from the civil war, the different tribes felt the effects of the civil war, which increased pre-existing tensions between groups there. The violence began when people in Darfur tried making their voice heard via violence, and the Janjaweed retaliated with more violence.
Darfur was not initially genocide when it began. It has since become genocide. Whole villages are being destroyed past the point of being inhabitable again. People are dying. Children are disappearing. It fits the definition. For more information, check out what Eric Reeves writes.
It all feels very far away from where I sit at my desk in Pittsburgh. And yet, I know it’s happening. There are people who have seen it who confirm it. There are articles appearing in the news with short sentences about it. Short sentences. Words.
I have known about what’s going on in Darfur for several years now. I've had friends working in Darfur as aid workers for those years. But somehow, the impact didn’t hit me until recently, when I tried studying to understand what’s going on there. I still don’t understand. I don’t think I ever fully will. But comprehension is dawning.
No longer are the short sentences I see hidden in the daily headlines simply words. There are meanings attached to these words. Genocide. The press throws it around so easily, not realizing it’s a bowling ball in a ping-pong game.
A final thought.
During the Rwandan genocide, the Red Cross was present in the country, which is traditionally a neutral organization. One aid member said that to be aware of the genocide and to do nothing about it was to contribute to the genocide, and he couldn’t do that anymore. So he spoke.
“In such circumstances, if you don’t speak out clearly, you are participating in the genocide. If you just shut up when you see what you see, and morally, ethically, you cannot shut up. It’s a responsibility to talk, to speak up.” (video)
So I blog. I’m not sure what can be said. What can be done. I have no on the ground answers. I know the pat answers here: pray, write to your congressman, go to awareness events, etc. But I feel very helpless.
In the circles of government, it’s a linguistic battle.
Words have power.
February 23, 2008
The Week of M-Words
Mugabe. Massacre. Murambi. Mokoto. Mobutu. Mozote. Morazan. Monterrosa. Marquez. Mercedes. Martinez. Marcos. Mam.
I dare you to not get these confused.
Partial Glossary:
Mugabe: Current leader of Zimbabwe. As in Breakfast with Mugabe, a play I saw last night with friends from my CNF program. The play toys with an interesting “What If?” As in—what if you could sit down with a controversial leader? How would you get access? What would he say?
Massacre: when many people are killed violently.
Murambi: a school in Rwanda where a massacre of Tutsis occurred in 1994. As in the film Massacre at Murambi, which is only five minutes long, and you should watch. It’s a beautiful, tragic, almost literary film and propaganda.
Mokoto: a town in Zaire where a massacre of Tutsis occurred in a cathedral in 1996. As described in Philip Gourevitch’s We wish to inform you that tomorrow we will be killed with our families.
Mobutu: the leader of Zaire when the Mokoto massacre took place.
Mozote: a village in El Salvador where a massacre occurred in 1981 (also partly in a cathedral). As described in Mark Danner’s book The Massacre at El Mozote.
Morazan: the province in which El Mozote is—or was.
Monterrosa, Marquez, Mercedes, Martinez, y mas: names of people in Danner’s book—whose relationships and identities I have yet to decipher.
Marcos: As in the village of San Marcos. A coffee plantation in Guatemala.
Mam: the largest language group in San Marcos.
I dare you to not get these confused.
Partial Glossary:
Mugabe: Current leader of Zimbabwe. As in Breakfast with Mugabe, a play I saw last night with friends from my CNF program. The play toys with an interesting “What If?” As in—what if you could sit down with a controversial leader? How would you get access? What would he say?
Massacre: when many people are killed violently.
Murambi: a school in Rwanda where a massacre of Tutsis occurred in 1994. As in the film Massacre at Murambi, which is only five minutes long, and you should watch. It’s a beautiful, tragic, almost literary film and propaganda.
Mokoto: a town in Zaire where a massacre of Tutsis occurred in a cathedral in 1996. As described in Philip Gourevitch’s We wish to inform you that tomorrow we will be killed with our families.
Mobutu: the leader of Zaire when the Mokoto massacre took place.
Mozote: a village in El Salvador where a massacre occurred in 1981 (also partly in a cathedral). As described in Mark Danner’s book The Massacre at El Mozote.
Morazan: the province in which El Mozote is—or was.
Monterrosa, Marquez, Mercedes, Martinez, y mas: names of people in Danner’s book—whose relationships and identities I have yet to decipher.
Marcos: As in the village of San Marcos. A coffee plantation in Guatemala.
Mam: the largest language group in San Marcos.
February 15, 2008
Contrasts in Communication
Scenario #1. Yesterday.
Poor communication.
In the Cathedral of Learning, I pass by a fellow MFA student, A, who is sitting with her computer. A says, “Hey Renee, how did your paper go today?”
Me: “My paper?” (Does she mean the paper I'm writing or the ones I'm grading?)
A: “Yeah, didn’t you submit a paper on Bolivia to that one conference?”
Me: “Yeah, but I never heard back from them. It wasn’t accepted.”
A: “But you gave the paper at like three this afternoon.”
Me: “I did?”
A: “Or, you were supposed to. Look:” A clicks a button on her computer, scrolls down the page, and shifts her screen in my direction.
Sure enough: 3pm. Renee's reading a paper about teaching in Bolivia.
Me: “Oh, my word. I had no idea.”
A: “Seriously? I was going to stop by and hear you. Good thing I didn’t.”
Oops. It’s like one of those moments, standing on a bridge above a deep ravine, when the wind whips your favorite hat off your head, and you watch it drift and float down into the river… gone forever…
Scenario #2. Today.
Over-communication.
Mr. Stylist, with his John Travolta-like flip of bangs and sideburns, sits down next to me. “Renee, our new guest, welcome to our hair salon. Is our location convenient for you?”
“Yeah, I guess so. I live in Squirrel Hill.”
“Oh good! Location is everything in establishing professional relationships. I’m so glad our location is convenient for you. So, you’re employed by the University of Pittsburgh?”
“Yes. I’m a teaching assistant in the history department.”
“Oh good! A teacher. So you’re in front of students, and your appearance is important. So let’s go over to my station and into one of our guest robes, and we’ll get started!”
After donning the Hogwarts robe and following Mr. Stylist, I sit down in front of a mirror. He stands in front of me.
“So, Renee, when was your last haircut?”
“Thanksgiving—my sister cut it.”
“Thanksgiving. So that’s about three months ago. Renee, how often does your schedule allow for a haircut?”
“Um.”
“Every two weeks, four weeks, eight weeks, twelve weeks, sixteen weeks?”
“Sixteen weeks.”
“Well, Renee, if we establish this professional relationship, my work lasts about ten weeks. The longest you would want to go is twelve weeks.” He calculates a dollar amount. “That would be about $120 dollars a year on your hair. Would your schedule allow for that?”
“No, I don’t think so.”
“I’m sorry to hear that, Renee. Your hair is important, and needs a lot of care. Would you consider it?”
“Yes, I’ll consider it.” (Did I mention that this haircut is a free coupon from a friend of mine?)
“So what are you looking for today?”
“A trim with layers.”
“A trim with layers. Any boundaries to those layers?”
“Boundaries? I need to be able to pull it back into a ponytail.”
“Layers and a ponytail. That’s all you’re giving me?”
“Yes.”
“Okay, Renee. Your face is a geometric shape—kind of squarish. So, what I would like to do is use curves to soften that. Are you okay with that?”
“Yes, I’m okay with that.”
“Okay. Do you feel good about moving forward? Because I feel good about moving forward.”
“Yes. We can move forward.” Oh. My. Word. Get on with the hair-washing, already!
After the initial “establishing a professional relationship” conversation, not much was said, and we could get on with what I didn’t want to be a stressful experience. Here’s the result:
Poor communication.
In the Cathedral of Learning, I pass by a fellow MFA student, A, who is sitting with her computer. A says, “Hey Renee, how did your paper go today?”
Me: “My paper?” (Does she mean the paper I'm writing or the ones I'm grading?)
A: “Yeah, didn’t you submit a paper on Bolivia to that one conference?”
Me: “Yeah, but I never heard back from them. It wasn’t accepted.”
A: “But you gave the paper at like three this afternoon.”
Me: “I did?”
A: “Or, you were supposed to. Look:” A clicks a button on her computer, scrolls down the page, and shifts her screen in my direction.
Sure enough: 3pm. Renee's reading a paper about teaching in Bolivia.
Me: “Oh, my word. I had no idea.”
A: “Seriously? I was going to stop by and hear you. Good thing I didn’t.”
Oops. It’s like one of those moments, standing on a bridge above a deep ravine, when the wind whips your favorite hat off your head, and you watch it drift and float down into the river… gone forever…
Scenario #2. Today.
Over-communication.
Mr. Stylist, with his John Travolta-like flip of bangs and sideburns, sits down next to me. “Renee, our new guest, welcome to our hair salon. Is our location convenient for you?”
“Yeah, I guess so. I live in Squirrel Hill.”
“Oh good! Location is everything in establishing professional relationships. I’m so glad our location is convenient for you. So, you’re employed by the University of Pittsburgh?”
“Yes. I’m a teaching assistant in the history department.”
“Oh good! A teacher. So you’re in front of students, and your appearance is important. So let’s go over to my station and into one of our guest robes, and we’ll get started!”
After donning the Hogwarts robe and following Mr. Stylist, I sit down in front of a mirror. He stands in front of me.
“So, Renee, when was your last haircut?”
“Thanksgiving—my sister cut it.”
“Thanksgiving. So that’s about three months ago. Renee, how often does your schedule allow for a haircut?”
“Um.”
“Every two weeks, four weeks, eight weeks, twelve weeks, sixteen weeks?”
“Sixteen weeks.”
“Well, Renee, if we establish this professional relationship, my work lasts about ten weeks. The longest you would want to go is twelve weeks.” He calculates a dollar amount. “That would be about $120 dollars a year on your hair. Would your schedule allow for that?”
“No, I don’t think so.”
“I’m sorry to hear that, Renee. Your hair is important, and needs a lot of care. Would you consider it?”
“Yes, I’ll consider it.” (Did I mention that this haircut is a free coupon from a friend of mine?)
“So what are you looking for today?”
“A trim with layers.”
“A trim with layers. Any boundaries to those layers?”
“Boundaries? I need to be able to pull it back into a ponytail.”
“Layers and a ponytail. That’s all you’re giving me?”
“Yes.”
“Okay, Renee. Your face is a geometric shape—kind of squarish. So, what I would like to do is use curves to soften that. Are you okay with that?”
“Yes, I’m okay with that.”
“Okay. Do you feel good about moving forward? Because I feel good about moving forward.”
“Yes. We can move forward.” Oh. My. Word. Get on with the hair-washing, already!
After the initial “establishing a professional relationship” conversation, not much was said, and we could get on with what I didn’t want to be a stressful experience. Here’s the result:
February 14, 2008
A Tuesday God-Timed Package
“Good morning, Renee,” answers my dad’s voice on the phone.
“It is NOT a good morning!” I sob.
I hear him choke back a laugh—I agree--it may be a funny way to start a conversation, except it’s not. I am crying. I can’t even drink my coffee without fear of pouring salt water into it.
“Why isn't it a good morning?”
“Because it’s snowing!” I say.
In the background, I hear my mom say, “Is she joking?”
“No! I’m not joking! It’s snowing and I wanted to go shopping! I’ve been working really hard all weekend, and I was going to go shopping this morning as a treat. I hate shopping, but this time I was looking forward to it, and now it’s snowing! It’s the most snow I’ve ever seen in Pittsburgh and all the schools are closed and it’d be stupid to go driving in it.” My rant ends. I know how stupid it sounds.
Outside my window, the snow is falling fast and thick—with the big kind of snowflakes where you can literally see that each of them is uniquely patterned. I usually like this kind of snow. I’ve been waiting all winter for this kind of snow. And here it is… messing up my Tuesday plans.
“Well,” my dad says, “Can you take the bus?”
“Yes, but that’s not the point. And it’s way more fun to drive.”
“Okay.”
“The point is that I just found out that the independent study I’m taking won’t count for credit. I love this independent study—but it’s putting me over the edge with work—but I really enjoy what I’m studying. And now it doesn’t count!”
It’s true. I’m reading 11 books about Central American wars, and it won’t count as credit toward my English degree. It does, however, count as credit to make me a full-time student this semester so that I can be a funded student. So—there is a bit of a trade-off.
In this “independent study,” I’m examining the role of the creative nonfictionista in Latin America. The positionality of the writer, the angle he/she takes, how the “culture” is represented, etc. It’s invaluable to me—especially as I consider writing about my time in Bolivia. I can’t imagine this course not counting.
And yet—it does count. It’s a bit like those credit card commercials:
“Socially Engaged Writer” = 3 credits
“Writing Workshop” = 3 credits
“Modern Latin America TA” = Tuition
“Independent Study in Latin American CNF that informs manuscript writing and life in general” = priceless
Academic hoops and course credit are over-rated anyway.
Back to Tuesday morning.
I had known that the breakdown was coming—I could see it build with every book on war that I read. I just didn’t know when it would come. So it came on Tuesday morning. And really, all I needed to do was cry—let it out—deal with what I could—read a good book—eat some pudding—and then go on with life. But my parents had to hear about it.
My father couldn’t do anything. My mother couldn’t do anything. Turns out—they were with my grandparents, who both had to say “hello,” and neither of them could do anything either. It felt like that scene in Charlie and the Chocolate Factory where all of Charlie’s grandparents are sitting in one double bed, only this time they were passing around a cell phone. I know they weren’t—but still… they were all having their morning coffee together…
After I got off the phone with them, I checked my mailbox. There was a package in the hallway of my apartment building addressed to me. Unexpected package. Book package.
Inside, wrapped in silver paper, was a book entitled A Walk with Jane Austen.
A friend had read the book and decided that I had to read it too—so she sent it to me. A book with nothing to do with war and everything to do with Jane Austen arrived on my doorstep on the day that I could deal with war no longer.
A God-Timed Package Moment brought to you by… priceless.
Thanks, friend.
“It is NOT a good morning!” I sob.
I hear him choke back a laugh—I agree--it may be a funny way to start a conversation, except it’s not. I am crying. I can’t even drink my coffee without fear of pouring salt water into it.
“Why isn't it a good morning?”
“Because it’s snowing!” I say.
In the background, I hear my mom say, “Is she joking?”
“No! I’m not joking! It’s snowing and I wanted to go shopping! I’ve been working really hard all weekend, and I was going to go shopping this morning as a treat. I hate shopping, but this time I was looking forward to it, and now it’s snowing! It’s the most snow I’ve ever seen in Pittsburgh and all the schools are closed and it’d be stupid to go driving in it.” My rant ends. I know how stupid it sounds.
Outside my window, the snow is falling fast and thick—with the big kind of snowflakes where you can literally see that each of them is uniquely patterned. I usually like this kind of snow. I’ve been waiting all winter for this kind of snow. And here it is… messing up my Tuesday plans.
“Well,” my dad says, “Can you take the bus?”
“Yes, but that’s not the point. And it’s way more fun to drive.”
“Okay.”
“The point is that I just found out that the independent study I’m taking won’t count for credit. I love this independent study—but it’s putting me over the edge with work—but I really enjoy what I’m studying. And now it doesn’t count!”
It’s true. I’m reading 11 books about Central American wars, and it won’t count as credit toward my English degree. It does, however, count as credit to make me a full-time student this semester so that I can be a funded student. So—there is a bit of a trade-off.
In this “independent study,” I’m examining the role of the creative nonfictionista in Latin America. The positionality of the writer, the angle he/she takes, how the “culture” is represented, etc. It’s invaluable to me—especially as I consider writing about my time in Bolivia. I can’t imagine this course not counting.
And yet—it does count. It’s a bit like those credit card commercials:
“Socially Engaged Writer” = 3 credits
“Writing Workshop” = 3 credits
“Modern Latin America TA” = Tuition
“Independent Study in Latin American CNF that informs manuscript writing and life in general” = priceless
Academic hoops and course credit are over-rated anyway.
Back to Tuesday morning.
I had known that the breakdown was coming—I could see it build with every book on war that I read. I just didn’t know when it would come. So it came on Tuesday morning. And really, all I needed to do was cry—let it out—deal with what I could—read a good book—eat some pudding—and then go on with life. But my parents had to hear about it.
My father couldn’t do anything. My mother couldn’t do anything. Turns out—they were with my grandparents, who both had to say “hello,” and neither of them could do anything either. It felt like that scene in Charlie and the Chocolate Factory where all of Charlie’s grandparents are sitting in one double bed, only this time they were passing around a cell phone. I know they weren’t—but still… they were all having their morning coffee together…
After I got off the phone with them, I checked my mailbox. There was a package in the hallway of my apartment building addressed to me. Unexpected package. Book package.
Inside, wrapped in silver paper, was a book entitled A Walk with Jane Austen.
A friend had read the book and decided that I had to read it too—so she sent it to me. A book with nothing to do with war and everything to do with Jane Austen arrived on my doorstep on the day that I could deal with war no longer.
A God-Timed Package Moment brought to you by… priceless.
Thanks, friend.
February 11, 2008
Ha!
My brother just sent me this pix as a congratulations
for attaining a Masters in Ministry last August:
I'd love to sign up for the nearest Renaissance Faire! :)
February 10, 2008
Prom: Grad Style.
“Renee, we nominate you for most comfortable shoes.”
Two of my high school teachers said this to me while chaperoning my senior prom. I had worn brown leather Teva sandals under an incredibly funky dress. Descriptions honestly don’t do the dress justice: green long sleeves, four different types of natural-looking fabric, two patched tulips, and purple stitches—see? sounds ugly… but it wasn’t. The dress was funky elegant in its own way. It just wasn’t what everyone else was wearing to prom.
But I somehow had the guts to be individual, and the dress and my extremely long, curled hair won me the compliment of being a “woodland nymph princess.” There’s really no higher compliment one can give to a wanna-be citizen of Middle Earth.
Last night’s grad school prom was different. First of all, grad prom is not official. It consists of two of your classmates saying, “Hey, it’s February and boring—let’s have prom!” Second of all: those students select a bar to host the prom. Already, prom has changed.
Part of me wanted to wear the funky dress from high school, but it is in Michigan, and I’m in Pennsylvania. Instead, I wore what I perhaps should have worn to my high school prom: an elegant green bridesmaid dress, and ended up being the most normal looking person there.
Please picture for me, if you will, prom with MFA students—those artistic writerly types. There were outfits with sequins, plaid, or cowboy hats. An outfit straight out of “The Addam’s Family.” A white tux with sleeveless undershirts. The funky dress would have fit right in. Well, it’s nice to know I’m in the right place now.
(I’d post pictures, but my camera has been giving me the silent treatment. Lo siento!)
Two of my high school teachers said this to me while chaperoning my senior prom. I had worn brown leather Teva sandals under an incredibly funky dress. Descriptions honestly don’t do the dress justice: green long sleeves, four different types of natural-looking fabric, two patched tulips, and purple stitches—see? sounds ugly… but it wasn’t. The dress was funky elegant in its own way. It just wasn’t what everyone else was wearing to prom.
But I somehow had the guts to be individual, and the dress and my extremely long, curled hair won me the compliment of being a “woodland nymph princess.” There’s really no higher compliment one can give to a wanna-be citizen of Middle Earth.
Last night’s grad school prom was different. First of all, grad prom is not official. It consists of two of your classmates saying, “Hey, it’s February and boring—let’s have prom!” Second of all: those students select a bar to host the prom. Already, prom has changed.
Part of me wanted to wear the funky dress from high school, but it is in Michigan, and I’m in Pennsylvania. Instead, I wore what I perhaps should have worn to my high school prom: an elegant green bridesmaid dress, and ended up being the most normal looking person there.
Please picture for me, if you will, prom with MFA students—those artistic writerly types. There were outfits with sequins, plaid, or cowboy hats. An outfit straight out of “The Addam’s Family.” A white tux with sleeveless undershirts. The funky dress would have fit right in. Well, it’s nice to know I’m in the right place now.
(I’d post pictures, but my camera has been giving me the silent treatment. Lo siento!)
February 02, 2008
Book Reviews, #1
Since I posted the list of books I'm reading this semester, I thought I'd follow that up with some mini-reviews of those books throughout the semester.
Each book will get a recommendation number. 1 is low, 10 is high.
1 = “read only if you’re on a deserted island with no tree and you need something to put between your face and the sun.”
3 = “enh. read it if you must.”
8 = “enjoyed it. if you’re interested in the idea, you should read it.”
9 = “loved it. better than Coldstone ice cream.”
10 = “a must read for all of humanity.”
Children of the Roojme: A Family’s Journey from Lebanon by Elmaz Abinader.
Exactly what the subtitle says. Except that the subtitle doesn’t say that the first part will be in the voices of three generations of men in the family, and part two in the voices of three generations of women. The men travel back and forth between Lebanon, Brazil, and the U.S. The women wait for the men. The change of voice between the two parts is fascinating.
Recommend? 8
Perfume Dreams: Reflections on the Vietnamese Diaspora by Andrew Lam.
After the Americans pulled out but before the war was over, Lam (age 11) and his family left Vietnam in 1975. Now he’s a writer, and marrying his Vietnamese and American identities well in this book of essays.
Recommend? 7
Translated Woman: Crossing the Border with Esperanza’s Story by Ruth Behar.
Esperanza is a Mexican peddler who gives her life story to Behar over many sodas and late nights in Behar’s kitchen. Behar then takes the story to the US, transcribes it, reflects on it, and publishes it, making Esperanza a “literary wetback.” Fascinating study on the connection between writer and subject, writer and reader, subject and reader, etc.
Recommend? 7
Salvador by Joan Didion.
This is a report on Didion’s two weeks in El Salvador during June 1982. It’s problematic because of her relationship to the country and the way she portrays violence. Also, as a work of creative nonfiction, it didn’t have a very clear narrative arc… I wonder what my workshop class would say about the book. Also… it’s violent. But it’s about war, so it’s going to be. (Didion generally has a good reputation, though, so I’m going to suggest that this book is not representative of her work.)
Recommend? 3
“The Fall of Saigon” by James Fenton. In The Granta Book of Reportage.
This essay gets the reader straight into the heart of Saigon during the end of what Americans call the Vietnam War. Unfortunately, the reader has to view it all through the eyes of Fenton, who has some interesting thoughts. Fortunately, after reading it, I can see events in Saigon unfold before my eyes. Reading this before Perfume Dreams gives two different perspectives on Vietnam.
Recommend? 5
“The Mayflower Moment” by Patricia Hampl. In I Could Tell You Stories (all by Hampl).
She wrote my essay! I want to write an essay about Walt Whitman and Emily Dickinson! Fortunately, it’s not quite this essay. Hampl juxtaposes the first time she takes a birth control pill (her independence) with the landing of the Mayflower (a national independence) during the Vietnam War (a national… something) while reading Whitman (infinitely both personal and national). She does so much with this essay… that it’s simply wonderful.
Recommend? 9.
Disclaimer: This list is not comprehensive. In addition to this, I read and evaluate articles submitted by my classmates, other miscellaneous articles for class, and historical information on Argentina and Guatemala. And yes, that totals approximately 500 pages per week. I’ve been drinking a lot of tea. It’s cozy on a rainy Pittsburgh day (we apparently get more rain than Seattle? someone’s got to be making that up).
Each book will get a recommendation number. 1 is low, 10 is high.
1 = “read only if you’re on a deserted island with no tree and you need something to put between your face and the sun.”
3 = “enh. read it if you must.”
8 = “enjoyed it. if you’re interested in the idea, you should read it.”
9 = “loved it. better than Coldstone ice cream.”
10 = “a must read for all of humanity.”
Children of the Roojme: A Family’s Journey from Lebanon by Elmaz Abinader.
Exactly what the subtitle says. Except that the subtitle doesn’t say that the first part will be in the voices of three generations of men in the family, and part two in the voices of three generations of women. The men travel back and forth between Lebanon, Brazil, and the U.S. The women wait for the men. The change of voice between the two parts is fascinating.
Recommend? 8
Perfume Dreams: Reflections on the Vietnamese Diaspora by Andrew Lam.
After the Americans pulled out but before the war was over, Lam (age 11) and his family left Vietnam in 1975. Now he’s a writer, and marrying his Vietnamese and American identities well in this book of essays.
Recommend? 7
Translated Woman: Crossing the Border with Esperanza’s Story by Ruth Behar.
Esperanza is a Mexican peddler who gives her life story to Behar over many sodas and late nights in Behar’s kitchen. Behar then takes the story to the US, transcribes it, reflects on it, and publishes it, making Esperanza a “literary wetback.” Fascinating study on the connection between writer and subject, writer and reader, subject and reader, etc.
Recommend? 7
Salvador by Joan Didion.
This is a report on Didion’s two weeks in El Salvador during June 1982. It’s problematic because of her relationship to the country and the way she portrays violence. Also, as a work of creative nonfiction, it didn’t have a very clear narrative arc… I wonder what my workshop class would say about the book. Also… it’s violent. But it’s about war, so it’s going to be. (Didion generally has a good reputation, though, so I’m going to suggest that this book is not representative of her work.)
Recommend? 3
“The Fall of Saigon” by James Fenton. In The Granta Book of Reportage.
This essay gets the reader straight into the heart of Saigon during the end of what Americans call the Vietnam War. Unfortunately, the reader has to view it all through the eyes of Fenton, who has some interesting thoughts. Fortunately, after reading it, I can see events in Saigon unfold before my eyes. Reading this before Perfume Dreams gives two different perspectives on Vietnam.
Recommend? 5
“The Mayflower Moment” by Patricia Hampl. In I Could Tell You Stories (all by Hampl).
She wrote my essay! I want to write an essay about Walt Whitman and Emily Dickinson! Fortunately, it’s not quite this essay. Hampl juxtaposes the first time she takes a birth control pill (her independence) with the landing of the Mayflower (a national independence) during the Vietnam War (a national… something) while reading Whitman (infinitely both personal and national). She does so much with this essay… that it’s simply wonderful.
Recommend? 9.
Disclaimer: This list is not comprehensive. In addition to this, I read and evaluate articles submitted by my classmates, other miscellaneous articles for class, and historical information on Argentina and Guatemala. And yes, that totals approximately 500 pages per week. I’ve been drinking a lot of tea. It’s cozy on a rainy Pittsburgh day (we apparently get more rain than Seattle? someone’s got to be making that up).
February 01, 2008
What is a Blog?
Ever since I began this blog a year ago, I have been tossing around the idea of what it should look like. Should it be focused on a theme? Funny or serious? What is a blog? Why do people read blogs? Why would people read mine?
I check blogs for a myriad of reasons: to keep up with what friends are doing, to find out what they’re thinking, to see funny pictures of their children, to find information, to see stunning pictures of landscapes I’ll never visit, and to waste time when I can’t study any longer. Reading blogs is exactly what CS Lewis said, “We read to know we are not alone.”
So why do I keep a blog? Sometimes I’m not sure. I don’t think it’s so that I can pretend that I’m published or because I think my writing is the best. I don’t keep a blog for my resume or to impress my MFA friends… I think I keep a blog to tell stories.
“Telling stories” is a recurring theme in my life. Seven years ago, during a semester in Ireland, I read Frederick Buechner’s Telling Secrets with my class. In this book, Buechner writes that by telling our secrets we draw closer to God. He also agrees with Lewis, that by telling our secrets—our stories, we know that we’re not alone.
For instance, when I was little, one of my Canadian cousins and I wrote each other long, handwritten letters. I loved those letters—I knew that whatever happened in my life, I had a friend in Canada. I don’t write long letters to her anymore (now we have e-mail). I do know, however, that she checks this blog sometimes. And I check her Facebook pictures to see what her kids look like now. I watch her story through pictures of some adorable kids. [FYI: I’m NOT advocating replacing letters with blogs—that’s impersonal and silly. I’m advocating telling stories. Besides, blogs are morphing—there’s no clear definition yet.]
Last night in my literature class, we talked about the “Quest narrative” and why it’s important to read about other people’s quests. Same reason: to know that we’re not alone in carrying our little part of the world (which sometimes feels huge). Listening to or reading someone else’s story is one of the highest compliments we can give. By paying attention to someone’s journey, we’re saying, “You’re important. You have value.” To be a witness to someone else’s life is an act of compassion.
And sometimes, by reading someone else’s story, our own story comes more into focus. It’s kind of cool how it works that way.
So this blog isn’t topical. It isn’t focused on pictures or fancy graphics. It’s focused on the journey of life—and right now that looks like life as an MFA student teaching Latin American history in Pittsburgh. After the MFA, it’ll look like something different. And in the middle of the seasons of my life is a cabin in the dunes by Lake Michigan, a lake with new contours each spring…
Thanks for witnessing my story.
And by the way: the apartment today was a comfortable 72-75 degrees. Not the 58 degree tundra or the 81 degree sauna. It’s like having my own personal weather station. ☺
And if anyone knows how to edit the html to get my lake Michigan picture to fill the whole headline, I’d be grateful for the know-how.
I check blogs for a myriad of reasons: to keep up with what friends are doing, to find out what they’re thinking, to see funny pictures of their children, to find information, to see stunning pictures of landscapes I’ll never visit, and to waste time when I can’t study any longer. Reading blogs is exactly what CS Lewis said, “We read to know we are not alone.”
So why do I keep a blog? Sometimes I’m not sure. I don’t think it’s so that I can pretend that I’m published or because I think my writing is the best. I don’t keep a blog for my resume or to impress my MFA friends… I think I keep a blog to tell stories.
“Telling stories” is a recurring theme in my life. Seven years ago, during a semester in Ireland, I read Frederick Buechner’s Telling Secrets with my class. In this book, Buechner writes that by telling our secrets we draw closer to God. He also agrees with Lewis, that by telling our secrets—our stories, we know that we’re not alone.
For instance, when I was little, one of my Canadian cousins and I wrote each other long, handwritten letters. I loved those letters—I knew that whatever happened in my life, I had a friend in Canada. I don’t write long letters to her anymore (now we have e-mail). I do know, however, that she checks this blog sometimes. And I check her Facebook pictures to see what her kids look like now. I watch her story through pictures of some adorable kids. [FYI: I’m NOT advocating replacing letters with blogs—that’s impersonal and silly. I’m advocating telling stories. Besides, blogs are morphing—there’s no clear definition yet.]
Last night in my literature class, we talked about the “Quest narrative” and why it’s important to read about other people’s quests. Same reason: to know that we’re not alone in carrying our little part of the world (which sometimes feels huge). Listening to or reading someone else’s story is one of the highest compliments we can give. By paying attention to someone’s journey, we’re saying, “You’re important. You have value.” To be a witness to someone else’s life is an act of compassion.
And sometimes, by reading someone else’s story, our own story comes more into focus. It’s kind of cool how it works that way.
So this blog isn’t topical. It isn’t focused on pictures or fancy graphics. It’s focused on the journey of life—and right now that looks like life as an MFA student teaching Latin American history in Pittsburgh. After the MFA, it’ll look like something different. And in the middle of the seasons of my life is a cabin in the dunes by Lake Michigan, a lake with new contours each spring…
Thanks for witnessing my story.
And by the way: the apartment today was a comfortable 72-75 degrees. Not the 58 degree tundra or the 81 degree sauna. It’s like having my own personal weather station. ☺
And if anyone knows how to edit the html to get my lake Michigan picture to fill the whole headline, I’d be grateful for the know-how.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
