December 31, 2008

I miss Billy the Kid...

I miss Billy the Kid
the life that he lived
the time that he had
I guess he must have got caught
his innocence lost
Lord I wonder where he is
~Billy Dean

Last week in New Mexico, passing red rock cliffs boiling up from the desert countryside, my family and I saw signs that said, “Entering Billy the Kid Country.” The above country song popped into my head and stayed all week, so I often said, sighing, “I miss Billy the Kid!” What I really meant was, “I miss the Old West and I’m really excited to be here, in this Louis L’Amour-like scenery.”

My saying this drove my little sister nuts. So of course it became one of those things that one sister does to annoy the other. (Can’t you just see a vehicle of adults acting like children?) It really annoyed her when I picked up a book called Billy the Kid: the Endless Ride, a revisionist biography published by Norton, written by the voice of the sheriff from Cars. But since we were driving through The Kid’s territory on Christmas day, and all the museums and such were closed, I volunteered to be the tour guide.

Billy the Kid was 21 years old when he died in Lincoln, New Mexico, after being involved in a large-scale feud. Except for the feud, he really wasn’t anything special. But since he was on the under-dog side of the feud, he became a symbol, and his symbol exploded into the dime store novels that were on the rise in popularity in 1881. With the explosion of tales about him, his life became mythologized, and the actual details obscured.

This biography attempted to find the real Billy the Kid, most likely born as Henry McCarty to a Catherine McCarty, who probably emigrated from Ireland during the potato famine. Billy/Henry was born in either New York City or Indiana, then moved to Kansas, possibly Colorado, then New Mexico. He had a brother, Joseph, who was either older or younger but definitely physically bigger than him. In NM, Catherine died of tuberculosis and Joseph and Billy/Henry were taken in by separate families. Billy/Henry ran with the wrong crowd, ending up in jail at age 14. Because he was so small, he shimmied up the chimney and escaped from jail. He continued to make a habit of escaping from jail cells, which added to the legends.

Again because he was so small, he was often beaten by bigger men, so he learned to use a pistol—“the great equalizer”—to defend himself. He learned how to steal horses, one of the worst western crimes. Billy the Kid ran on the other side of the law in a lawless land. He spoke Spanish fluently and was revered by the “little man” for standing up to the “big men.” And then he ended up in Lincoln with the feud and was murdered. End of story.

Except not the end of the story. He continued to live on in stories, becoming a symbol. In the song I quoted at the beginning, as well as the way in which I invoked his name in New Mexico, he is romanticized as the epitome of the Old West. And yet, it was the lawlessness and corruption of the Old West that eventually killed him.

So what is it that we miss, when we miss Billy the Kid or the Old West? It seems to be the individual standing up against all odds—and hopefully winning. There’s the rugged lonely Louis L’Amour cowboy, rescuing the pioneer woman who lost her family and is about to lose her ranch. Then there’s the land, imposing, intimidating, and demanding intimate reverence. There’s the element of the American Dream—that we can strike out on our own and make it big. That there is gold to be found. Paradise on the other side. California or bust—it will be the fulfillment of our dreams, and if we end up in Seattle—well, it’s pretty there too.

We forget about the men who ran around with guns in a posse. The mistreatment of the mislabeled Indians. The frigid cold of the outhouse in the winter. The lone woman teaching a one-room schoolhouse of children, exhausted beyond her capabilities. The drought. The plagues. The gold that ran out. The lack of vegetables in the winter. The elementary medicine. The inevitable, constant presence of fear.

Nearly 127 years after the death of Billy the Kid, I watched New Mexico fly by windows of a full-size van, Billy’s biography in my lap. We passed through Lincoln, where he made his final jail escape and was finally killed. Just down the street is a large Lincoln-log fence surrounding a theatre, where every first weekend in August, Billy the Kid’s life is dramatized. We pulled into the parking lot, sat in a moment of silent reverence, and then continued on down the road. There was nothing else to do in that town.

So in essence, I don’t miss Billy the Kid. Not really. I definitely miss the romanticized version of the L’Amour cowboy. But I wouldn’t want to live in a land run by guns—even though I have been a fair shot the rare times I’ve had target practice. If I really wanted the lawless adventure of the West, there are a few places on earth I could go for that adventure. And if I wanted a frozen outhouse, I could just go snow-camping with my cousins in Canada.

No, the adventure I think I miss is the land. We spent Christmas day zigzagging across the entire state of New Mexico, and I barely read the biography, simply watching the vegetation, the cliff crags, the outline of the stone against the blue sky. I love it when nature breaks in and demands attention with beautiful snowstorms, steep grades, sunsets, and wide-open spaces lined by rocky horizons. On my list of fun things to do, there are few activities higher than a day spent hiking or swimming. Generally, if I see a 300ft cliff, I want to rappel down it—cactus or no cactus. These are the adventures I miss, when I miss Billy the Kid.

When I’m honest, I really don’t miss the Old West. I enjoy the modern conveniences of indoor plumbing, heating systems, the Internet, and the electric light entirely too much to give them all up. But I do start to suffocate with too much cement around me. In that way, I really do envy Billy the Kid and all his horse thievery and wide open spaces.


I should have been a cowboy
I should have learned to rope and ride
I might’ve had a sidekick with a funny name
Running wild through the hills chasing Jesse James
Or ending up on the brink of danger
Riding shotgun for the Texas Rangers
~Toby Keith

I’ll be your Belle Starr
and you can be my Jesse James
~EmmyLou Harris (& Mark Knopfler)

December 20, 2008

A Christmas Reflection

In addition to hanging out with family and all that jazz, the holidays are generally a time for spiritual reflection. Of course, if you know me, simple daily chores usually spark spiritual reflection. Christmas just gives me an added excuse to share these reflections. Christmas—the celebration of the birth of Christ. God made flesh. God as human. God as Jesus. A loose translation of John 1 would read that Jesus came and made his tent among us.

And then I take this idea further. When Jesus left earth, he left with us his spirit and his peace.

“Peace on earth, goodwill toward men (and women).” That’s very Christmas-y.

Last Friday, I toyed with the ideas of Jesus’ spirit and peace while subbing for a gentle yoga class. Our studio’s definition of a gentle yoga class is a class where we don’t ever stand up. It’s an incredibly peaceful class—an amazing end to a workweek and a glorious beginning to the weekend. The class starts after dark, and with the dim glow of Christmas lights from the street, we don’t even need the studio lights. It’s like moving softly inside a snow globe.

The tradition of Anusara yoga speaks of inviting grace into the body. According to Desiree Rumbaugh, the idea is that if one experiences grace inside the body through yoga, one might take it off the mat and into daily life. Practiced consistently enough, this might alter how one responds to life on a regular basis. Knowing how yoga has changed my life—how it has radically altered my internal dialogue—I love this idea of experiencing grace within the body.

But why stop with grace? Why not peace as well?

Generally, I think of peace as more of a physical feeling than grace. Perhaps that’s because grace (unmerited favor / undeserved blessing) can be a theologically weighted term (which I almost got into with this post, but that wouldn’t have been very peaceful!). Peace is a calm we crave in our muscle fibers, a blanket of serenity we want in our minds.

While on earth, Jesus promised us his peace: “Peace I leave with you; my peace I give you. I do not give to you as the world gives. Do not let your hearts be troubled and do not be afraid” (John 14:27). As God incarnate, Jesus did not give conditionally. He gave us his unconditional peace. A peace that the apostle Paul says is beyond our understanding (Phil 4:7).

When I think of Jesus’ peace—which is here but that I don’t often feel—and his spirit, I think of the breath. Yoga is all about the breath, drawing life-giving oxygen in, pushing toxic carbon dioxide out. Drawing life-giving peace in, pushing toxic anxiety out.

So in my yoga class Friday night, we invited peace into our bodies and thus our lives. By moving slowly and being kind to our hamstrings and our shoulders and our thoughts, we felt peaceful. At the end of class, watching my students linger on their mats before picking up, I saw peace on their faces. And it certainly wasn’t my peace, because by myself I am not peaceful.

This is why I love mixing yoga and Christianity—the yoga helps me experience what through Christianity I supposedly know to be true. And although you and I are not in a yoga class right now as I write and you read, I hope the peace of Christ manifests itself in your life this Christmas...


Namaste.

Almost the last post before Christmas

Tomorrow my brother and sister board a plane in Michigan, and I’ll board one here in Pennsylvania. We’ll convene in Albuquerque, New Mexico, where our parents will pick us up and take us to their new house in Nowheresville. My dad is so excited—all his little ducklings under one roof for a whole week! (Really, it’s quite endearing.)

It’s been a long time since the five of us have been in the same place without distraction—no extended family members, no significant others, no running out to meet a friend for coffee. We’re going to be stuck together—and I think we’re all excited, and a little nervous too. There’s nothing like people who share your blood to get your blood boiling.

It seems that most of the people I talk to feel the same way about seeing family this Christmas—a little apprehensive, but a little excited too. The holidays sometimes bring up crazy emotions.
In teaching yoga, I’m learning to coach my students through “riding out the wave” of emotion that comes from holding a pose. Our bodies store our emotions, and stretching our muscles often releases pockets of those emotions. In the same vein, relationships of people who have known us forever also store pockets of emotions. Being with them releases emotions we often avoid. In my life, I’m learning how to “ride the wave” of the emotions that relationships bring too—good or bad waves.

That said, I’m expecting mostly good waves this week. I love my family. All of us have changed a lot over the past couple of years, and it’s fun to re-get-to-know each other. My parents and I talk often on the phone, and it will be lovely to chat over morning coffee rather than morning airwaves. My sister and I, complete opposites, balance each other out well and generally unite with spontaneous dance parties. (If we include the Beatles, the BeeGees, and Fleetwood Mac in the music mix, Mom joins us too.) And my exuberant brother entertains us all, regaling us with stories and ideas we would never have thought of on our own.

I’m excited, too, about the change of scenery (high altitude, dry NM) and the change of pace. Coconut the cat and I have been a bit tired of each other’s company. She watches my every move as I pack, knowing that something is up. Tonight I’m taking her to hang out with my friend CS for the week, and I’m sure she’ll enjoy the plethora of windows in his apartment. I’m excited to trade talking to a ball of fur for talking with the four people I’ve known longer than anyone else on the planet.

I’m even going to make it into an official vacation: the computer is staying at home. Any writing I do will be pen and ink. I’ll have my books, too. But no MFA pressure. None, nada, zilch. Merry Christmas, Renee—a week with family and no school. Yipee!

December 17, 2008

The "If" Game...

If Synecdoche and Twilight and Battlestar Galactica got into a fight, who would win?

This is a fun game. One of my college roommates played it all the time:
“If Norah Jones and Jack Johnson got into a fight, who would win?”
“If Raskolnikov and Frankenstein’s Creature got into a fight, who would win?”
“If the Grille cookies and Krispy Kreme doughnuts got into a fight, who would win?”

Last night, walking out of the movie Synecdoche, I wondered—if Synecdoche and Twilight got into a fight, who would win? And I totally mean the book Twilight, not the movie. From what I know of the movie, there would be no contest. Of course, since Synecdoche is going to lose against the book, comparing the movies might be more fair.

Ever since I hit my absolute emotional edge last week while writing final projects, I’ve been indulging in melodramatic narrative. I love it. I’m now halfway through Twilight, completely addicted. I’ve dropped blog hints that I’m already addicted to Battlestar Galactica (BSG). And then, last night, I saw Synecdoche.

Today I obtained the next BSG disc, and I have a decision to make: do I watch the disc or read Twilight. Horrible decision. I don’t know which to choose. So let’s weigh the three…

Honestly, Synecdoche loses. First of all, it is the odd-ball out. In comparing apples and grapes and broccoli, Synecdoche is broccoli. It’s an existential movie with a lot of play on literary devices—hence the title. “Synecdoche,” the literary device, is when a part represents a whole. The movie plays with this in a hyperbolic way, which makes for a great, complex narrative. I loved the way it played with the trope of death following the main character around as an actual character. Its focus, however, leaves a bit to be desired. I expected the ending to be a bit more profound than it actually was, which, perhaps was the point. So—it loses against Twilight.

The writer response: As a writer, I’m starting to have several responses to narratives--the viewer/reader response and the craft response. For Synecdoche, the writer in me sees it as a commentary on memoir-writing—or creating art solely about one’s life. At one point, actors ask the main character, “Are we ever going to get an audience in here? It’s been 17 years…” Pieces of the movie are a call out of artistic navel-gazing. I don’t think it’s saying that art should not be affiliated with the artist’s life, just that an ego-centric approach might not be too valuable to the audience (who just might not be there). The writer-response is outside of the who-beats-who game.

Twilight. I’ve devoured a thousand pages, and this story still has my rapt fascination. It’s bringing out the 14-year-old girl in me, and I love it. Cracks me up, really, with all the melodramatic action between the main characters. Every time I think, “Wouldn’t it be nice if ____ happened?” it’s in the next sentence. This makes it sound predictable—it’s not. The main character makes surprising decisions, which makes her a strong enough character to follow through a story like this too… Now, when I walked through the bookstore and saw the cheesy vampire display, I was horrified that I was reading the books and liking them. I’m attributing the cheesiness of the display to the movie. I really like the black-red-white covers that leave the character visualization to the imagination. However, by nature of only having three fascinating characters, Twilight loses against BSG.

The writer response: Using all the bad dialogue I try not to write, the story weaves around a fundamental question with a moral spin. Will it happen? When? What will happen when it does? (Sorry—trying not to throw what “it” is in, so as not to spoil anyone’s read, although you’ll figure out the question by the end of the first book.) I’m watching—how does she weave this question through? How does she intensify it? What question will drag people through my book?

BSG flat-out wins. Its narrative is much more complex and fulfilling than Synecdoche (which is an unfair comparison, since S only gets two-ish hours and BSG gets four years—but S could barely fill its two hours without me wanting it to be done, so… ). Its characters are light-years more complex than Twilight, and forever more unpredictable. BSG plays with every rule in every dimension outside the book, and always leaves me wanting the next episode. I have a feeling that very soon it’s going to make me cry, which will then turn into anger…

I will watch all four episodes on the disc today, and then turn to Twilight for solace when it’s over. At least this disc has four episodes. (That unpredictability really does make me angry.) Also I will write a proper review of BSG in a later post.

The writer response: I have not yet figured out its narrative secret—other than that BSG has many writers, and I’m only one. Perhaps the element of unpredictability would be a nice one to mimic. One problem: BSG sets a premise where anything can happen, and I am limited to real life and that which actually did happen. Stink. Magical realism and fiction, why am I not writing you?

If fiction and creative nonfiction got into a fight, who would win?

December 11, 2008

Today's Motto

For every hour I'm pushing myself through writing this last essay, my inner dialogue sounds more and more like a cheesy cheerleader. Now, the cheerleader isn't even using words. It's just this image:


December 10, 2008

When I am done

I'm in the middle of a writing blitz right now, which is actually good. Although it's a little overwhelming to think of how I'll churn out 10-13 pages over the next 24 hours, the stuff I'm writing right now is good. I like it. It's energizing. I'm excited about these pieces... which makes the lack of sleep a little more worth it.

Now that the final deadline is 24 hours away (I finished one deadline today), I feel that I can start to think about what I'll do when I'm done. I'm posting the list here, and putting it away so that I can concentrate.

After I turn in my final piece, I'm going to... in no particular order...

1. Sleep.
2. Clean my apartment. (I know, it sounds Monica-dorky, but I do celebrate finishing lots of work by cleaning it all up!)
3. Watch a double feature of The Office and Grey's Anatomy. (I love having friends with DTV!)
4. Read the first two books of the Twilight series straight-through.
5. Watch the next disc of Battlestar Galactica, also straight-through. (I'm somewhere in season 3...)
6. Attend fun end-of-the-year parties.
7. Talk to people I've ignored for the past week.
8. Write fiction. Ha!
9. Go Christmas shopping?
10. Read the other four million books I've been neglecting...
Basically? I'm going to be a vegetable.

Finally: eat on a regular schedule. gosh. that sounds nice.

December 04, 2008

a semester of Sanskrit

My Sanskrit final is due tomorrow. It's a translation of a very wise parable. I took minor liberties with the literal word-for-word version into the following fluid version:


Mahatapas & the Mouse

Once upon a time, in the Gautama Forest, there was a sage by the name of Mahatapas. In the neighborhood of his ashram, he saw a baby mouse fall from the crow’s mouth. The compassionate sage nourished the baby mouse with small grains of wild rice. The sage had also seen a cat running after the mouse to eat it.

So, from the yogic power of asceticism, the sage made the mouse into a powerful cat. That cat was afraid of the dog, so he was made into a dog. That dog was afraid of the tiger, so he was made into a tiger. Now then, the sage saw him, even though he was a tiger, as no different from a mouse.

Then, having seen the tiger, all the people standing there said, “By this sage, this mouse was transformed into a tiger.”

Hearing this, the dismayed tiger thought, As long as this sage lives, then this story of my own humiliating form will not go away. Thus, having thought so, he set about to kill the sage.

But the sage, having known the tiger’s intention, said, “Be a mouse again,” and the mouse was made only a mouse.

So, I say:
A lowly person, having arrived at an honorable position, wants to harm the master, just as the mouse, having become a tiger, was going to kill the sage.

December 03, 2008

On Writing

"I wrote an essay I'm kind of proud of today. And that hasn't happened in the whole year and a half I've been in the MFA program. It was the most fantastic day writing that I've ever had."

When I heard myself say this to a friend tonight, I had a couple of reactions to my own statement.

1) Really? In the past year and a half I haven't written anything I'm proud of? Nope. Check with my friend hmb--I haven't sent her anything I've written. And I usually do when I write something that makes me giggle.

2) What does that say about my MFA program? I like my program. I don't like the writing I do in it. Why is that? A question to explore...

3) I didn't leave my apartment until dinnertime. And I had a full day's work. It was as if I wasn't even home... I even forgot about lunch, I was so absorbed in my writing--and it wasn't boring. I mean, it's not boring to talk about. I can go out with friends and say, "work was interesting today... and I didn't even see anyone." Writing is an experience.

I don't think writing is always easy and absorbing. Or that it should be. But gosh darn it, it should be rewarding and productive sometimes. It's not that I think today's essay is the best thing since sliced bread... it's that I think it has potential. I think it's artistic, maybe poetic, and it's definitely different than anything else I've tried.

It is a lyric essay. Lyric meaning that it flows like a poem with a cadence, a rhythm, and imagery. Essay meaning that it's trying something, discussing something, and doesn't solve anything.

Maybe I should say that it felt like creating art.

Other times, when I've written something for workshop, it feels like pulling an anchor out of the water. The narrative is moored in mud. Getting it out of the mud requires standing on the bow and pulling with every ounce of body weight not used for balance. Once it's flowing, it's still hand-over-hand drudgery as the bowling ball of non-aerodynamic weight pushes against water and the water pushes back. Once the anchor is free of the water, it needs to be handled with great care so that it doesn't hit the boat, slosh water over the cushions, or dump mud on the white interior. Holding weight with a rope at an awkward angle is tedious.

But I had fun writing this essay. I read it aloud to myself, checking its sounds. Cringing at bold statements, I wondered if I might be burned at the stake if I publish it. And then I realized that I could publish this one. It could get to that point.

I just might be a writer.

"But, Renee!" You say with exasperation. "You already are a writer!"

Yes, I know. And you have been telling me that for years. But this day, I realized I might someday be a professional writer--providing the economy decides to smile again. And that (the professional writer part, not the economy part) makes me smile.

December 01, 2008

Oh, yoga.

Today, I received the following card from my mother:



I call it the "mad yoga cat."

Oh, yoga, you poor trendy thing, made to be the laughingstock of hallmark, pop songs, and sitcoms. Eventually, your popularity will fade, and people will stop making fun of you.

Until then, those of us who wish to be more flexible will envy the natural sass of the feline.

I'm still cracking up at this picture. It's the perfect muse for the end of the semester writing blitz.