I miss Billy the Kid
the life that he lived
the time that he had
I guess he must have got caught
his innocence lost
Lord I wonder where he is
~Billy Dean
the life that he lived
the time that he had
I guess he must have got caught
his innocence lost
Lord I wonder where he is
~Billy Dean
Last week in New Mexico, passing red rock cliffs boiling up from the desert countryside, my family and I saw signs that said, “Entering Billy the Kid Country.” The above country song popped into my head and stayed all week, so I often said, sighing, “I miss Billy the Kid!” What I really meant was, “I miss the Old West and I’m really excited to be here, in this Louis L’Amour-like scenery.”
My saying this drove my little sister nuts. So of course it became one of those things that one sister does to annoy the other. (Can’t you just see a vehicle of adults acting like children?) It really annoyed her when I picked up a book called Billy the Kid: the Endless Ride, a revisionist biography published by Norton, written by the voice of the sheriff from Cars. But since we were driving through The Kid’s territory on Christmas day, and all the museums and such were closed, I volunteered to be the tour guide.
Billy the Kid was 21 years old when he died in Lincoln, New Mexico, after being involved in a large-scale feud. Except for the feud, he really wasn’t anything special. But since he was on the under-dog side of the feud, he became a symbol, and his symbol exploded into the dime store novels that were on the rise in popularity in 1881. With the explosion of tales about him, his life became mythologized, and the actual details obscured.
This biography attempted to find the real Billy the Kid, most likely born as Henry McCarty to a Catherine McCarty, who probably emigrated from Ireland during the potato famine. Billy/Henry was born in either New York City or Indiana, then moved to Kansas, possibly Colorado, then New Mexico. He had a brother, Joseph, who was either older or younger but definitely physically bigger than him. In NM, Catherine died of tuberculosis and Joseph and Billy/Henry were taken in by separate families. Billy/Henry ran with the wrong crowd, ending up in jail at age 14. Because he was so small, he shimmied up the chimney and escaped from jail. He continued to make a habit of escaping from jail cells, which added to the legends.
Again because he was so small, he was often beaten by bigger men, so he learned to use a pistol—“the great equalizer”—to defend himself. He learned how to steal horses, one of the worst western crimes. Billy the Kid ran on the other side of the law in a lawless land. He spoke Spanish fluently and was revered by the “little man” for standing up to the “big men.” And then he ended up in Lincoln with the feud and was murdered. End of story.
Except not the end of the story. He continued to live on in stories, becoming a symbol. In the song I quoted at the beginning, as well as the way in which I invoked his name in New Mexico, he is romanticized as the epitome of the Old West. And yet, it was the lawlessness and corruption of the Old West that eventually killed him.
So what is it that we miss, when we miss Billy the Kid or the Old West? It seems to be the individual standing up against all odds—and hopefully winning. There’s the rugged lonely Louis L’Amour cowboy, rescuing the pioneer woman who lost her family and is about to lose her ranch. Then there’s the land, imposing, intimidating, and demanding intimate reverence. There’s the element of the American Dream—that we can strike out on our own and make it big. That there is gold to be found. Paradise on the other side. California or bust—it will be the fulfillment of our dreams, and if we end up in Seattle—well, it’s pretty there too.
We forget about the men who ran around with guns in a posse. The mistreatment of the mislabeled Indians. The frigid cold of the outhouse in the winter. The lone woman teaching a one-room schoolhouse of children, exhausted beyond her capabilities. The drought. The plagues. The gold that ran out. The lack of vegetables in the winter. The elementary medicine. The inevitable, constant presence of fear.
Nearly 127 years after the death of Billy the Kid, I watched New Mexico fly by windows of a full-size van, Billy’s biography in my lap. We passed through Lincoln, where he made his final jail escape and was finally killed. Just down the street is a large Lincoln-log fence surrounding a theatre, where every first weekend in August, Billy the Kid’s life is dramatized. We pulled into the parking lot, sat in a moment of silent reverence, and then continued on down the road. There was nothing else to do in that town.
So in essence, I don’t miss Billy the Kid. Not really. I definitely miss the romanticized version of the L’Amour cowboy. But I wouldn’t want to live in a land run by guns—even though I have been a fair shot the rare times I’ve had target practice. If I really wanted the lawless adventure of the West, there are a few places on earth I could go for that adventure. And if I wanted a frozen outhouse, I could just go snow-camping with my cousins in Canada.
No, the adventure I think I miss is the land. We spent Christmas day zigzagging across the entire state of New Mexico, and I barely read the biography, simply watching the vegetation, the cliff crags, the outline of the stone against the blue sky. I love it when nature breaks in and demands attention with beautiful snowstorms, steep grades, sunsets, and wide-open spaces lined by rocky horizons. On my list of fun things to do, there are few activities higher than a day spent hiking or swimming. Generally, if I see a 300ft cliff, I want to rappel down it—cactus or no cactus. These are the adventures I miss, when I miss Billy the Kid.
When I’m honest, I really don’t miss the Old West. I enjoy the modern conveniences of indoor plumbing, heating systems, the Internet, and the electric light entirely too much to give them all up. But I do start to suffocate with too much cement around me. In that way, I really do envy Billy the Kid and all his horse thievery and wide open spaces.
I should have been a cowboy
I should have learned to rope and ride
I might’ve had a sidekick with a funny name
Running wild through the hills chasing Jesse James
Or ending up on the brink of danger
Riding shotgun for the Texas Rangers
~Toby Keith
I’ll be your Belle Starr
and you can be my Jesse James
~EmmyLou Harris (& Mark Knopfler)
I should have learned to rope and ride
I might’ve had a sidekick with a funny name
Running wild through the hills chasing Jesse James
Or ending up on the brink of danger
Riding shotgun for the Texas Rangers
~Toby Keith
I’ll be your Belle Starr
and you can be my Jesse James
~EmmyLou Harris (& Mark Knopfler)

