Showing posts with label literature. Show all posts
Showing posts with label literature. Show all posts

July 10, 2008

On reading a novel.

At a used book sale last week, I picked up a novel. Over the last year or two, novel-reading has become more of a treat than chocolate. Since I’m studying nonfiction and I feel incredibly behind my classmates in common-creative-nonfiction knowledge, I usually feel compelled to read nonfiction—but it isn’t nearly as satisfying as fiction.

When I read a novel, I’m gone. Absorbed. Transported. Somewhere else. Some people call this escapism, which is said with a sneer. I disagree—it’s more like traveling mentally. There’s something exotic about curling up with a novel about India or Mars or Middle Earth and meeting ents or IT or monsoons. Even something as nonexotic as a baseball game can be enthralling in a book. (And, honestly, via fiction is the only way I’m going to be enthralled at a baseball game anyway—whether I’m reading about the game or reading during the game: same difference.) Friends of mine in college actually remarked that I seemed happier when I had a novel in progress.

I haven’t read a novel since January. (That’s not true—I did finish one about baseball. That’s where I figured out that Pittsburgh’s baseball team is named the Pirates. Now I won’t get them confused with the Steelers. Ha! I’m almost joking.)

So you might be able to imagine my delight when I discovered that my summer teaching gig allows for time with novels—both mentally and physically. I could open one, read it, and not feel guilty for not reading nonfiction. M.M. Kaye’s Shadow of the Moon and I have been fantastic friends for the past week. Kaye and I have had brief, unproductive encounters before—she’s quite dense and history-heavy at times. But this time… I pushed through the first one hundred pages and was as captured in place as the heroine: Winter.

And that’s where this story ends: there is no epiphany about how Winter’s life parallels mine—because it doesn’t. I’m not an Indian heiress, literally or figuratively, so you can now consider this the anti-climax of this post. I enjoyed a novel. I thought the world should know. M.M. Kaye is not on the historical level of James Michener, nor is she of the page-turning equivalent of Mary Higgins Clark, and her characters are not as heart-breakingly complex as Margaret Mitchell’s Scarlett O’Hara and Rhett Butler. But she can weave a good yarn. She must be for eight hundred pages of suspense, complicated with colonial tension. That was a good summer read.

I’m just sorry it’s over. Instead of reading tonight, I find myself blogging—which isn’t all bad.

Any other good novel suggestions?
I think I’m off for an M.M. Kaye adventure in Zanzibar.

February 29, 2008

Further Thoughts

On Wednesday, Philip Gourevitch (author of We wish to inform you… see previous post) gave a reading and a Q & A on Pitt’s campus. He discussed the typical writing and researching—and then he got into politics. He’s incredibly opinionated and amazingly knowledgeable. I wish he announced the nightly international news (then it might actually be international!). Since I had already been thinking about Darfur and intervention, etc, as I listened to him talk, I applied some of it to what I know about Darfur.

Intervention is a funny thing—it appears simple and never, ever is. To go in for purely humanitarian reasons is a rare thing. It would be a nice thing, but it rarely happens because intervention cannot be separated from politics. Whenever two or more countries are involved, there is always a political aspect. (Whenever just one country is involved, there are always politics!)

Gourevitch made this connection clear. There are always politics. AND, if one or more countries are not going in with the best interest of the people affected in the country, they simply shouldn’t go. It’s not fair to the people affected to use them for political reasons.

At the same time that I’ve been reading and listening to Gourevitch, I’ve been studying the Twelve Year War in El Salvador. (1980-1992) In the late years of the Cold War, U.S. involvement in El Salvador was disturbingly political and allowed for major violations of human rights. (See The Massacre at El Mozote by Mark Danner for more info.)

In addition to learning about the histories of Rwanda and El Salvador, I’ve been learning and teaching Modern Latin American history as a teaching assistant. The professor of the course requires the students to write “State of the Nation” essays at major time points in Latin American history. These essays are to analyze the political, economic, and social patterns of the country, and a good essay (I tell them) describes the overall relationships between these three patterns.

The political, economic, and social aspects of a country cannot be separated. In El Salvador, the political turmoil opened the door for major social atrocities. In Rwanda, the three are so intertwined I would need three pages for the thesis statement alone (so see Gourevitch’s book, because he’s already described it). And in Darfur…

This is what I know: these matters are so complex that they cannot be taken lightly. The more I learn, the more I learn that I will never learn it all. There will always be more.

I have no answers. But a step toward seeking to understand the complexity seems to be a step in the right direction.

I think, by the way, that this is one of the reasons why I love writing: I’m learning history and politics (and even some economics!)—all in an MFA program for writing. Go figure. Writers have such opportunities to be interdisciplinary that it’s overwhelming. Thanks go to Gourevitch and various professors for opening these doors for me…

February 27, 2008

Genocide: Words have power.

Anyone who reads this blog regularly knows that I am reading over 20 books on violence this semester. Here’s the latest installment on my thoughts.

Last week, I gave a presentation on genocide. C—my project partner—and I led a class discussion on the book We wish to inform you that tomorrow we will be killed with our families by Philip Gourevitch. We wish is about the 1994 Rwandan genocide. And, if that wasn’t gloomy enough, we connected the Rwandan situation to Darfur.

Other than the time frame, the situations in Rwanda and Darfur appear similar: people are dying in Africa. Under the surface, however, the situations are very different. When C asked a refugee from Darfur about the similarities, the man looked at us quizzically. He said, “They are not the same. The conflict in Rwanda was tribal. The conflict in Darfur is religious.” But then he followed it up with, “Well, there are some similarities. In both cases, people die. Both are major genocides of the 21st century.”

A friend of mine currently in Darfur wrote, “Rwanda was clearly a genocide (even those who denied it while it was happening knew they were lying) but Darfur […is] a bit more questionable. They […] share a racial dynamic to them that is fascinating (and terrible) to look at, but I would warn against any type of broad brush strokes between the[m].” Darfur is NOT genocide? Wait… then what exactly is genocide?

If the difference between Rwanda in 1994 and the current situation in Darfur lies in the word “genocide,” then the similarity is there, too. (That’s weird logic, but hang with me.)

The word “genocide” was coined by a man named Raphael Lemkin, who was a Polish Jew in Europe before World War II. In the aftermath of a genocide in Armenia during WWI, he became fascinated with mass slaughter (as it was called before “genocide”), and began studying law to find a way to stop it. He identified Hitler’s rise to power as problematic, but no one listened to him. As a Jew, in 1939, he was forced to flee Europe.

Lemkin fled to the United States, where he continued his campaign to end mass slaughter, urging the international community to come together in order to stop such events from ever happening again. At some point, he realized that the crime needed a name. In addition to law education, Lemkin also had had linguistic training, and understood the importance of words. He named the crime “genocide,” which is Greek, “geno,” for race, Latin, “cide,” for kill. He published a book with the word, and continued to lobby to for laws to recognize genocide as a crime against humanity. (For more, check out Samantha Power’s book, “A Problem from Hell.”)

In 1946, a year after WWII ended, the United Nations recognized the concept of genocide. And in 1948, the Genocide Convention wrote the following definition:
“genocide means any of the following acts committed with intent to destroy, in whole or in part, a national, ethnical, racial or religious group, as such: (a) Killing members of the group; 
(b) Causing serious bodily or mental harm to members of the group; 
(c) Deliberately inflicting on the group conditions of life calculated to bring about its physical destruction in whole or in part; 
(d) Imposing measures intended to prevent births within the group; 
(e) Forcibly transferring children of the group to another group.” (genocidewatch.org)

After the document written by the 1948 Genocide Convention was ratified, genocide was recognized as an international crime. Once a crisis has been recognized as genocide, the international community then has an obligation to stop it.

According to www.genocidewatch.org, there are eight stages in genocide:
1. Classification
2. Symbolization
3. Dehumanization
4. Organization
5. Polarization
6. Preparation
7. Extermination
8. Denial
(I like genocidewatch.org’s definitions for these eight stages because it also outlines possible ways of preventing genocide at each stage.)

Back to Rwanda and Darfur:

Rwanda’s genocide followed each of these stages in a linear fashion. The Hutus and the Tutsis used language to divide and “Other.” The genocide occurred. And now, in some areas, it is being denied. In his book, Gourevitch points out a unique aspect of the Rwandan genocide: in no other genocide were the two sides ever expected to live side-by-side in the same country after the genocide.

Darfur’s genocide has not followed each of these stages in a linear fashion, and perhaps this is one of the reasons why international policies have been slow to respond. In the beginning, maybe it was fundamentally a religious problem. Sudan’s civil war was predominantly between the North and the South, Islamic and Christian regions, respectively. In the western province of Darfur, far removed from the civil war, the different tribes felt the effects of the civil war, which increased pre-existing tensions between groups there. The violence began when people in Darfur tried making their voice heard via violence, and the Janjaweed retaliated with more violence.

Darfur was not initially genocide when it began. It has since become genocide. Whole villages are being destroyed past the point of being inhabitable again. People are dying. Children are disappearing. It fits the definition. For more information, check out what Eric Reeves writes.

It all feels very far away from where I sit at my desk in Pittsburgh. And yet, I know it’s happening. There are people who have seen it who confirm it. There are articles appearing in the news with short sentences about it. Short sentences. Words.

I have known about what’s going on in Darfur for several years now. I've had friends working in Darfur as aid workers for those years. But somehow, the impact didn’t hit me until recently, when I tried studying to understand what’s going on there. I still don’t understand. I don’t think I ever fully will. But comprehension is dawning.

No longer are the short sentences I see hidden in the daily headlines simply words. There are meanings attached to these words. Genocide. The press throws it around so easily, not realizing it’s a bowling ball in a ping-pong game.

A final thought.

During the Rwandan genocide, the Red Cross was present in the country, which is traditionally a neutral organization. One aid member said that to be aware of the genocide and to do nothing about it was to contribute to the genocide, and he couldn’t do that anymore. So he spoke.

“In such circumstances, if you don’t speak out clearly, you are participating in the genocide. If you just shut up when you see what you see, and morally, ethically, you cannot shut up. It’s a responsibility to talk, to speak up.” (video)

So I blog. I’m not sure what can be said. What can be done. I have no on the ground answers. I know the pat answers here: pray, write to your congressman, go to awareness events, etc. But I feel very helpless.

In the circles of government, it’s a linguistic battle.

Words have power.

February 14, 2008

A Tuesday God-Timed Package

“Good morning, Renee,” answers my dad’s voice on the phone.

“It is NOT a good morning!” I sob.

I hear him choke back a laugh—I agree--it may be a funny way to start a conversation, except it’s not. I am crying. I can’t even drink my coffee without fear of pouring salt water into it.

“Why isn't it a good morning?”

“Because it’s snowing!” I say.

In the background, I hear my mom say, “Is she joking?”

“No! I’m not joking! It’s snowing and I wanted to go shopping! I’ve been working really hard all weekend, and I was going to go shopping this morning as a treat. I hate shopping, but this time I was looking forward to it, and now it’s snowing! It’s the most snow I’ve ever seen in Pittsburgh and all the schools are closed and it’d be stupid to go driving in it.” My rant ends. I know how stupid it sounds.

Outside my window, the snow is falling fast and thick—with the big kind of snowflakes where you can literally see that each of them is uniquely patterned. I usually like this kind of snow. I’ve been waiting all winter for this kind of snow. And here it is… messing up my Tuesday plans.

“Well,” my dad says, “Can you take the bus?”

“Yes, but that’s not the point. And it’s way more fun to drive.”

“Okay.”

“The point is that I just found out that the independent study I’m taking won’t count for credit. I love this independent study—but it’s putting me over the edge with work—but I really enjoy what I’m studying. And now it doesn’t count!”

It’s true. I’m reading 11 books about Central American wars, and it won’t count as credit toward my English degree. It does, however, count as credit to make me a full-time student this semester so that I can be a funded student. So—there is a bit of a trade-off.

In this “independent study,” I’m examining the role of the creative nonfictionista in Latin America. The positionality of the writer, the angle he/she takes, how the “culture” is represented, etc. It’s invaluable to me—especially as I consider writing about my time in Bolivia. I can’t imagine this course not counting.

And yet—it does count. It’s a bit like those credit card commercials:
“Socially Engaged Writer” = 3 credits
“Writing Workshop” = 3 credits
“Modern Latin America TA” = Tuition
“Independent Study in Latin American CNF that informs manuscript writing and life in general” = priceless

Academic hoops and course credit are over-rated anyway.

Back to Tuesday morning.

I had known that the breakdown was coming—I could see it build with every book on war that I read. I just didn’t know when it would come. So it came on Tuesday morning. And really, all I needed to do was cry—let it out—deal with what I could—read a good book—eat some pudding—and then go on with life. But my parents had to hear about it.

My father couldn’t do anything. My mother couldn’t do anything. Turns out—they were with my grandparents, who both had to say “hello,” and neither of them could do anything either. It felt like that scene in Charlie and the Chocolate Factory where all of Charlie’s grandparents are sitting in one double bed, only this time they were passing around a cell phone. I know they weren’t—but still… they were all having their morning coffee together…

After I got off the phone with them, I checked my mailbox. There was a package in the hallway of my apartment building addressed to me. Unexpected package. Book package.

Inside, wrapped in silver paper, was a book entitled A Walk with Jane Austen.

A friend had read the book and decided that I had to read it too—so she sent it to me. A book with nothing to do with war and everything to do with Jane Austen arrived on my doorstep on the day that I could deal with war no longer.

A God-Timed Package Moment brought to you by… priceless.

Thanks, friend.

February 02, 2008

Book Reviews, #1

Since I posted the list of books I'm reading this semester, I thought I'd follow that up with some mini-reviews of those books throughout the semester.

Each book will get a recommendation number. 1 is low, 10 is high.
1 = “read only if you’re on a deserted island with no tree and you need something to put between your face and the sun.”
3 = “enh. read it if you must.”
8 = “enjoyed it. if you’re interested in the idea, you should read it.”
9 = “loved it. better than Coldstone ice cream.”
10 = “a must read for all of humanity.”

Children of the Roojme: A Family’s Journey from Lebanon by Elmaz Abinader.
Exactly what the subtitle says. Except that the subtitle doesn’t say that the first part will be in the voices of three generations of men in the family, and part two in the voices of three generations of women. The men travel back and forth between Lebanon, Brazil, and the U.S. The women wait for the men. The change of voice between the two parts is fascinating.
Recommend? 8

Perfume Dreams: Reflections on the Vietnamese Diaspora by Andrew Lam.
After the Americans pulled out but before the war was over, Lam (age 11) and his family left Vietnam in 1975. Now he’s a writer, and marrying his Vietnamese and American identities well in this book of essays.
Recommend? 7

Translated Woman: Crossing the Border with Esperanza’s Story by Ruth Behar.
Esperanza is a Mexican peddler who gives her life story to Behar over many sodas and late nights in Behar’s kitchen. Behar then takes the story to the US, transcribes it, reflects on it, and publishes it, making Esperanza a “literary wetback.” Fascinating study on the connection between writer and subject, writer and reader, subject and reader, etc.
Recommend? 7

Salvador by Joan Didion.
This is a report on Didion’s two weeks in El Salvador during June 1982. It’s problematic because of her relationship to the country and the way she portrays violence. Also, as a work of creative nonfiction, it didn’t have a very clear narrative arc… I wonder what my workshop class would say about the book. Also… it’s violent. But it’s about war, so it’s going to be. (Didion generally has a good reputation, though, so I’m going to suggest that this book is not representative of her work.)
Recommend? 3

“The Fall of Saigon” by James Fenton. In The Granta Book of Reportage.
This essay gets the reader straight into the heart of Saigon during the end of what Americans call the Vietnam War. Unfortunately, the reader has to view it all through the eyes of Fenton, who has some interesting thoughts. Fortunately, after reading it, I can see events in Saigon unfold before my eyes. Reading this before Perfume Dreams gives two different perspectives on Vietnam.
Recommend? 5

“The Mayflower Moment” by Patricia Hampl. In I Could Tell You Stories (all by Hampl).
She wrote my essay! I want to write an essay about Walt Whitman and Emily Dickinson! Fortunately, it’s not quite this essay. Hampl juxtaposes the first time she takes a birth control pill (her independence) with the landing of the Mayflower (a national independence) during the Vietnam War (a national… something) while reading Whitman (infinitely both personal and national). She does so much with this essay… that it’s simply wonderful.
Recommend? 9.

Disclaimer: This list is not comprehensive. In addition to this, I read and evaluate articles submitted by my classmates, other miscellaneous articles for class, and historical information on Argentina and Guatemala. And yes, that totals approximately 500 pages per week. I’ve been drinking a lot of tea. It’s cozy on a rainy Pittsburgh day (we apparently get more rain than Seattle? someone’s got to be making that up).

January 16, 2008

A Dark, Dank, and Dreary Semester?

Check out the list of books I'll be reading this semester. I'd provide you with links... but there's so many of them that I just don't have the time. If you're curious: google it.

For the course "Modern Latin America" (the one for which I'm a teaching assistant):
Born in Blood and Fire: A Concise History of Latin America
A Lexicon of Terror: Argentina and the Legacies of Torture
Buried Secrets: Truth and Human Rights in Guatemala

For "The Socially Engaged Writer"
Children of the Roojme: A Family's Journey from Lebanon
Chameleon Days: An American Boyhood in Ethiopia
The Business of Memory: The Art of Remembering in an Age of Forgetting
We wish to inform you that tomorrow we will be killed with our families
A Good War is Hard to Find: The Art of Violence in America
I Could Tell You Stories: Sojourns in the Land of Memory
The Granta Book of Reportage
Perfume Dreams: Reflections on the Vietnamese Diaspora
Regarding the Pain of Others

For "Independent Study of Latin American Creative Nonfiction"
Translated Woman: Crossing the Border with Esperanza's Story
Salvador
Children of Cain: Violence and the Violent in Latin America
From Grandmother to Granddaughter: Salvadoran Women's Stories
The Weight of All Things
The Massacre of El Mozote
Paradise in Ashes: A Guatemalan Journey of Courage, Terror, and Hope
Silence on the Mountain: Stories of Terror, Betrayal, and Forgetting in Guatemala
I, Rigoberta Menchu: An Indian Woman in Guatemala
The Rigoberta Menchu Controversy
Guatemala: Never Again!

For "Creative Nonfiction Writing Workshop"
various chapters from my fellow classmates (some violent, some not)
various chapters from heroes of my fellow classmates (so we can imitate them)

My initial thoughts:
a) that's A LOT of books.
b) I like to read
c) that's a lot of books about violence and terror
d) who wants to read this many books about violence and terror?
e) If you contact me between now and April, send me happy thoughts. :)

Actually, though, I'm looking forward to this semester. All of the literature and coursework is focused on the role of the creative nonfiction writer--the writer who is half-memoirist, half-journalist--in the world, specifically Latin America. At least it's all concentrated in a particular area and not scattered into so many areas I'd have to compartmentalize myself. This is all very focused and interesting...

Good thing this is the spring semester--the sunlight during the day gets longer and the world gets warmer and hopeful from here on out... :)

December 15, 2007

What IS Creative Nonfiction?

Now that I’ve finished one semester of an MFA program in creative nonfiction, I ought to be able to give you a definition. When people have asked what I’m studying, their responses to the term “creative nonfiction” tend to sound a bit like this:

“Isn’t that an oxy-moron?”
“I tell creative nonfiction stories every day.”
“Oh, like that James Frey guy?”
“How is that a genre?”

Before I started the Creative Nonfiction (CNF) program at the University of Pittsburgh, I thought that CNF was simply memoir-like writing—real story. My story. Or stories.

Apparently, memoirs are only one branch of CNF. CNF originally branched out of journalism, not autobiography. Major “new journalist” CNF writers are writers like John McPhee, Gay Talese, Tracy Kidder, or Joan Didion. These writers pick an interesting subject, immerse themselves in the subject world for awhile, and then write an article about it using a nonfiction narrative (real story) to convey the information—but it reads more like a novel. So, to paraphrase Mary Poppins, the story makes the information go down.

So: a simple definition of CNF might read like this: Creative Nonfiction is a genre that uses a real story in order to convey information. It has a frame and a focus. Usually the focus is a “greater truth” that applies to people universally. The “greater truth” is what makes a subject like robots apply to nearly every reader.

My own definition of CNF tends to combine a bit of the life experience with the research. It’s somewhere between memoir and immersion journalism. Like Annie Dillard.

That said: my original ideas of writing my own stories have been a bit discouraged this semester. My professor says that people in their twenties are too young to be writing memoirs—unless they have had some killer experiences. I wouldn’t consider my experiences to be killer—but I wouldn’t consider them to be dull either. However, I am still too close (time-wise) to my Bolivia experiences to really write that book. I think. We’ve definitely been encouraged to do more of the immersion-style of CNF.

By the end of my program, I need to have written 200 pages of CNF. We’ll see what comes of it.

Until then, here are some of my favorite CNF books:
An American Childhood, by Annie Dillard (the setting is Pittsburgh!)
Reading Lolita in Tehran, by Azar Nafisi
Eat, Pray, Love, by Elizabeth Gilbert (except the end)
Ex Libris, by Anne Fadiman
Dakota, by Kathleen Norris

November 15, 2007

The Templar Knights

I once substituted for a class with an eleven-year-old student who freaked out extremely easily. While taking math quizzes, if he didn't know an answer, he would literally start to pull out his hair and his face would get all red and he'd stop breathing and... it was quite the production. During my literature class this semester, I began to understand how this kid felt. My lit colleagues talk philosophy and I start to write thinly disguised metaphors about how I'm sitting at a potluck choking on the chicken bones someone else forgot to take out of their casserole.

At least, this is how I felt until this week. Until the Templars. The Templar Knights, no less.

These knights are not the swashbuckling King Arthur kinds of knights on whom I might develop one of those irrational-literature-hero crushes; these are the knights who supposedly guard the secret that "The DaVinci Code" revealed to the world. The secret that "could bring down the church." No irrational crushes there.

But I did develop an irrational fixation on this week's reading for lit class. We read the "history book" that Dan Brown apparently used as one of his sources for the DaVinci Code. And I thought it was hilarious.

In "The Templar Revelation," the authors tour around France, where Mary Magdalene is supposedly buried. They uncover the secret that the Templars and a plethora of other covert groups worship both Mary Magdalene (who was married to Jesus) and John the Baptist (whom Jesus rivaled for power). They used anything from interviews to archeaological findings to the New Testament to the Gnostic gospels to DaVinci paintings to support their theory.

And they're not alone in their findings. In class, my professor produced a dozen other texts and a 29 page bibliography of similar books with similar claims. As a group, we discussed marketing, motives, audience, etc. We discussed oppositional history. We discussed why it hasn't affected the church. We discussed... well, lots of things.

For once, I understood the whole conversation. No pulling out my hair this week or writing covert poems. No pulling the "I just want to write!" writer card.

When these historians cite the Bible and other well known Bible researchers, I don't need to fact check by going to the source--I understand what they're talking about and can debunk it without secondary sources. I think that was the fun of reading "The Templar Revelation" this week. I understood what was at stake if the claims were true (and knew they weren't), and I understood the philosophical conversation around the texts. And I enjoyed thinking about them anyways.

Some of the people in the class wondered why people inside the Church would read books like "The DaVinci Code" if they were so heretical. Many people I know don't, and many do. Why do I like reading books that are oppositional to what I believe? Because I like knowing why I think/believe/know what I do. I like looking at things from another perspective. It helps my beliefs become clearer.

Earlier I mentioned, "Oppositional History." This kind of history--written from the perspective of the (supposed) Other--has become very popular in the past few decades. One of the texts we read suggest that this is because some people are either dissatisfied or satisfied by what the present looks like. Reading books like "The Templar Revelation" or "The DaVinci Code" helps me understand why some people are dissatisfied with the Church as it is. And I enjoy turning that over in my mind, as well as if it's true, and if it should be that way, and how that may or may not affect my attitude...

What can I say? I like thinking.

And then, when I start wanting to pull out my hair because I'm thinking too much, I know it's time to stop. And go on to a novel. So I get a book on CD.

Title? "The Templar Legacy." Yes. The same stuff in novel form. :)

November 05, 2007

Chimamanda Ngozi Adichie

So, I seem to be experiencing an inverse proportion equation of sorts. Tonight I went to my third Drue Heinz Lecture of the year (a series of lectures from writers) and, unlike the other two lectures (Nafisi and Patchett), tonight I had not read a book by the author.

For the lecture given by Azar Nafisi, an author I had read and loved, I sat in the second balcony, far enough above her head to not see the glint from her glasses. In order to hear Ann Patchett, I sat off to the left, in the shadowy wings of the orchestra floor. And tonight, with a ticket I got for free for an author I had never read, I sat in the dead center of the second row.

It seems that the less I know of an author, the closer to her I get to sit.

I was not bored. Chimamanda Adichie engaged her audience from the first word: speaking of imagining bagels, reading Chinua Achebe for the first time, walking into her American dorm room, and writing what she knows. Not even five years older than I am, she is the author of two novels about Nigeria, and working on a third. Lectures given by storytellers are hard to recap, so I shall give you the titles of her books, both of which are now on my "to read list," which is long enough to reach to the non-planet Pluto and back:

Purple Hibiscus, 1st novel
Half of a Yellow Sun, most recent novel

Introducing: H M B

Hot Metal Bridge is two things: a bridge in Pittsburgh, the city of bridges. It is also a new online literary journal that just published its second issue. In the spirit of Halloween, the theme for this issue is "Headless." Published by the University of Pittsburgh's graduate English department, this literary journal is pretty cool. You should check it out. (And, if you check the "About" section, you might find me, too!)

http://hotmetalbridge.org


PS. Seriously, I would link that for you, but I cannot find the hyperlink button on the "create post" page in Blogger. Does anyone know where it went? Or is my computer just temperamental?

October 29, 2007

Harry Keeps Pushing Boundaries

Harry Potter's latest debate is an interesting one in the world of literary criticism. Last week, J.K. Rowling confirmed that Albus Dumbledore is gay. Now, here's the interesting part for me: this fact, ultimately, is not in the seven Harry Potter books (but will now make it into the eventual Encyclopedia, I'm sure), and is also not important to the books. As the NY Times critic writes, "Dumbledore’s supposed gayness is ultimately as unimportant as Ron’s shabby clothes." (The NY Times writes whole articles on fictional characters? Pretty important.)

So, if Dumbledore's sexuality is unimportant to the books and yet, post-writing, the author says that he is gay, literary criticism is in a bit of a conundrum. Criticism based on authorial intent--interpreting the story by what the author intends to say--will now go back and reinterpret all the novels with this new piece of information. Rowling has wisely managed to stay out of much of her novels' interpretations until now, just dropping well-phrased hints now and then before the release of a new book. Her readers have been able to take whatever they want to the text, which is another school of literary criticism: reader response. In this method of interpretation, the books mean whatever the reader interprets it to mean. So, if the reader puts all the clues together, realizes that Dumbledore's never had a significant other, then the reader can interpret that however he/she wishes.

There are several other schools of interpretation, but only one that I will mention here: structuralism. This method looks at the text alone--authorial intent or reader response aside--the critic looks at the text and derives meaning from it alone. Meaning is constructed from the clues in the text. Structuralism operates under the assumption that the text and the author are not inseparable and that the text can often have meaning that the author does not mean it to have.

When I come to a text, I usually pay attention to all three of these schools of thought. I pay attention to my reaction to a text, but usually separate it from my ultimate artistic critique of the text. I pay attention to the author's comments about the text, and find them interesting--but if I see something totally different than the author intended, that's alright as well. When I write essays, I use dominant structuralist methods, adding nuances from authorial intent or my response.

So, until now, my readings of Harry Potter have been mostly structuralist. I've always wondered where Rowling would take the novels in the end, and now that they are finished, her intent no longer matters. The seven novels, as they stand together on the shelf, are a complete, huge story. For her to "come out" with a comment like this, post-writing, is an interesting move of rhetorical (and political?) strategy. Does this alter structuralist readings of the text? Should it? Can we now discuss the Harry Potter novels without Dumbledore's sexuality? Or is it now an important element of the text? Pure structuralism would say that this new information is unimportant and unfounded. Yet, this new authorial information has made such a splash that part of me thinks I'll have to stretch my structuralist boundaries to fit it in... It makes me wonder if these books will continue to construct their own meaning outside of the text for awhile yet. Rowling has said that she will eventually write an encyclopedia, which will give further background on several characters and situations. I wonder how many new meanings will be in store for her readers there...

October 20, 2007

American Visa

I spent Thursday night back in Bolivia. No, I did not fly to La Paz physically, just mentally. Juan de Recacoechea, author of American Visa, one of ten Bolivian novels ever to be translated into English, came to campus on his book tour. During his lecture before the film rendition of his novel, Juan spoke about the creation of his novel, the differences between it and the movie, and his thoughts on Bolivia’s current president. The only attendees to this lecture (other than me) spoke fluent Spanish, and I was one of two tall gringos in the room—just like it usually was when I lived in Bolivia.

A Bolivian novelist from La Paz. While I lived in Bolivia, I did not get into their literary scene all that much (might have improved my Spanish, though!), so this was a new adventure for me. Juan introduced “crime pulp fiction” to Bolivia and won a prestigious award for his novel in 1994. Not bad.

I had not read the book, so a review of the film is all I can give you. It is about a man from Oruro who wants to go to Miami in order to visit (or stay indefinitely with) his son. In the process of trying to get his visa, he meets a “night butterfly” and becomes involved in a night mystery. It is as if he is a Bolivian version of Dostoevsky’s Raskolnikov, which was literarily fascinating to me. The movie was also fascinating in that it depicted a part of Bolivia I had never seen: the night life of La Paz. I doubt it’s a part of Bolivia that I will ever want to see.

And now, I am back in Pittsburgh—where the leaves are changing RIGHT NOW. Maple and sassafras trees seem to be going first—sassafras having already turned, and maple mid-turn. The oak trees are still waiting. I love the brilliance of the color—especially yesterday, when it was set against a dreary dark blue rain cloud. Welcome autumn.

September 10, 2007

The rise of another hero...

If I were an Iranian English literature professor, I would want to be Azar Nafisi. So, maybe I'll just be her American equivalent... or something of the sort.

Last spring I read Nafisi's Reading Lolita in Tehran, which is a fabulous account of teaching English literature in Iran during the Iranian Revolution, which started in 1979. She incorporates politics, literature, and life while describing the private class she taught in her home. Through the book, the powerful theme of how reading literature shapes our paradigm rang true with my own experience.

In small and large ways, my own experience while teaching English literature and writing in Bolivia parallels Nafisi's experience in Iran. In fact, this is one of the book ideas I'm currently considering for my MFA manuscript. Experiences like teaching "The Declaration of Independence" during the same week President Goni resigned under political and physical pressure provide good fodder for such a book.

All this to say: one of my favorite authors right now is Azar Nafisi. And guess what? In two weeks, she's coming to Pitt.

http://www.pittsburghlectures.org/interior.php?pageID=135

What happens to a dream deferred? I don't think it does dry up like a raisin in the sun, Mr. Hughes.

September 07, 2007

Ode to Madeleine

It has always been my dream to meet and talk with author Madeleine L'Engle. In 1995, I came close at a conference at Calvin College. Madeleine was one of the speakers, and I passed within a foot of her in a crowd of people. She was in a wheelchair because she'd injured her leg in a car accident. As I passed her in the crowd, she was napping her (being 75 years old and sleepy), and the person guiding her chair refused her adoring fans.

I had always hoped that our paths might cross again. Maybe I'd visit New York and find the Cathedral of St. John the Divine, where she was writer in residence. Maybe I'd hear her at another conference and stand in the book signing queue. Or... maybe not.

Today her publishing house announced that she died of natural causes. You can read about it here: link to NY Times. Or you can continue reading my tribute. Or both.

Perhaps one of the two most influential books on my life was written by Madeleine L'Engle: Walking on Water--Reflections on Faith and Art (The other being Bird by Bird by Anne Lamott). L'Engle's book talks about what it means to her to be a writer with faith in God. What it means to her to be a writer with faith in God while watching her father wrestle with weak lungs as a result of being in WWI. She writes about writing with faith during WWII. She writes about writing for children--which she didn't intend to do. She wrote for herself and the books ended up marketed towards young adults. She consistently gives children the benefit of the doubt: do not write down to them, for then they won't listen. And, best of all, she taught me that writing is engaging in a great conversation of written words throughout time.

Though I doubt L'Engle ever visited Bolivia, she was with me there through her words. For me, to read L'Engle in Bolivia was like crawling into a chair with an old friend--and that, perhaps above all reasons, is why I write today. In Bird by Bird, Lamott urges writers to write for the writers who wrote before them--to give back to them a piece of what they've given. I once started a letter to L'Engle... but I never finished it. I look forward to sitting with her in a hammock in heaven and talking about writing and faith and life.

You probably know L'Engle as the author of A Wrinkle in Time, which hopefully some teacher made you read at some point in life. It's on the top banned books in the United States--up there with literary hellions like Huck Finn. If you haven't read it, you should.

L'Engle's favorite theme to work with--especially in her time quartet--is that the smallest acts can have the most profound influence. That the smallest pieces inside us matter in the cosmos. That love conquers over all. Her fiction is filled with strong hope. Her nonfiction is filled with honest struggles, and how she either resolves them or lives with them.

What most people don't know is that she did not write only for young adults. While half of her books can be found in the young adult fiction section of the library, another fourth is adult fiction, and the last fourth in adult nonfiction. (And she dabbled in picture books, playwriting, and poetry--a decidedly well-rounded author.) Though much of her writing is from a Christian perspective, her books--fiction or non--won't be found in a Christian bookstore. She is, perhaps, a bit on the left side of things, which I didn't realize when I read her in high school--and probably wouldn't have dissuaded me anyways. She was right--what you read as a child shapes you. And Madeleine L'Engle shaped much of me.

So, I am sad to learn of her passing--sad for my own selfish reason of wanting to meet her on this planet--sad because a great woman has left this world for the next, and is not here to influence us anymore. Ha! But she is--she has left her legacy, her books, and her words. The smallest words--written or spoken--still change lives.

In the words of Mel: Madeleine, I pledge you.

July 24, 2007

Harry Potter: my official stance.

My admiration for Harry Potter began during high school while I worked at a children’s bookstore. This was before the books were popular, and people would walk in and say, “I need a good read aloud for fifth grade boys.” We would point them to Harry Potter and the Sorcerer’s Stone and then Chamber of Secrets. With names like Albus Dumbledore and Dudley Dursley (‘Ittle Diddykins) and inventions like Parseltongue and Quidditch, what 11 year old boy could resist? Harry’s impetuous, reckless, gangly luck and destiny enchanted… nearly everyone, eventually.

I finally read them on the afternoon of my high school graduation, several months before the release of Prisoner of Azkaban. It was one of the first warm days of summer, and I stretched out in the sun and fell into Harry’s world like he fell into the Pensieve. Hours later, I pulled back into the world of Muggles—only to discover that I had been burned in the encounter. My sunburned legs were on fire and Madame Pomfrey was not around to put them out with magical aloe. The damage was done—my legs are now freckled for life. However easily I burn, I now know I can join the Weasley clan with the descriptive word “ginger” to describe my complexion—much better than arguing about orange, red, or auburn.

Shortly after I left for college, West Michigan erupted into one of the hotter wars over Harry Potter in the schools. One of the public school superintendents banned Harry from his libraries. The management of the children’s bookstore where I had worked took Harry off their shelves and sold it from “behind the counter.” Conservative Christians wrote scathing editorials in the local paper. And those of us who had read it and loved it watched as the name “Harry Potter” became as taboo as “Lord Voldemort.” We fought back with our own editorials and opinions. Eventually, the superintendent lifted the ban and the controversy subsided, rising again every few years with the release of a new book.

As the “Harry Potter phenomenon” picked up speed, the Christian controversy was highlighted several times on a national level. As Goblet of Fire and Order of the Phoenix came out, it was apparent that the books were getting “darker,” and I realized that some of the controversy had merit (but only some). Though I admired Rowling’s incredible details, I decided to continue to be silent until the last Harry Potter books was released, and then I would make my final judgment. Until then, as I started teaching high school English in Christian schools, I treated Harry Potter like Christian teachers discuss Jesus in public schools—if the student brings him up first, then I could continue the conversation.

Enter Book Seven: Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows. After inhaling the book so quickly I literally gulped to breathe, eight years of Christian tension rolled off my back—I can say with confidence that I fully endorse reading Harry Potter. Fully endorse. No reservations. J.K. Rowling far exceeded my expectations with the last book (other than the epilogue—which is bound to be cheesy in any book). On my next read of the books, I will start making notes for my dissertation regarding Harry Potter and God and why I think reading fantasy literature is an asset to one’s faith and not a danger. Books Five, Six, and Seven in particular have incredible quotes…

I want to go into more detail here as to why I think this—but, considering that this 759 page book has only been in print for four days, you’ll have to wait for that dissertation (you think I’m joking!). All I can say is that Rowling is a genius and I wish that they had not made Movie Five until after Seven had been released. Also—it contains a dragon.

My favorite quote from Seven: “Of course it is happening inside your head, Harry, but why on earth should that mean that it is not real?” ☺ Vindicates many years of living inside my ginger head with some very real characters—my freckles and I love it up here.

July 02, 2007

Scholarship

So, this past spring, I received a paper back from a professor with a note that said, "Fix up this paper, and submit it to this conference out East." So, last week I fixed up that paper and e-mailed it to the conference people. And guess what? It's in. I am presenting a paper that I wrote on "The Role of the Roll in The Pilgrim's Progress" at a conference in August. Woohoo!

In the world of academia, this is one of the ways to get your name out--to present your ideas at a conference. So... here I go. :)

May 14, 2007

On Shakespeare and Spiderman.

On Saturday I encountered both Shakespeare and Spiderman. Since then, I've been trying to tie the two experiences together for the sake of an interesting blog, and I think I have the link: Language.

Shakespeare: I tried out for a Shakespeare acting company. I'm not an actress. I loathe the stage. I'm uncomfortable as the center of attention. But I love Shakespeare. I love his language, his plot lines, his characters, and everything that comes with that silly iambic pentameter guru. So, just for kicks, I auditioned to see what an English teacher could do up against a handful of newly-graduated-theatre-majors.

My 124 minutes in the audition were awkward, strange, funny, and enlightening. Theatre people do warm-ups that seem sillier to me than most yoga poses. They are also more adept at memorizing than I am, but I already knew memorizing was a weakness of mine. Acting the part of Perdita from "A Winter's Tale," however, was fun when I was given actions to go along with my words. Whenever I felt awkward, I concentrated on the language and slid back into being comfortable with acting. The language drew me along past anxiety, and I ended up being more entertained than nervous, which was all I had asked of myself anyway.

Spiderman III: I usually like the Spiderman movies. Though I had been warned before walking into this one, I still had expected it to be good. I did not expect to feel as awkward as I had in the Shakespeare audition--but I did. Why? Because of the language. It wasn't foul or crass, only weak. In particular, the dialogue was weak. Instead of relaxing into the language, I checked the time. Like in any movie, there were a few good lines and quotes that have stuck with me, but for the most part, I struggled with the language--and a little of the plot. I missed Shakespeare's tight plot lines.

Though the language was not up to my literary standards, I'm not going to leave Spidey with a horrid review. Thematically, the movie was solid. With themes of friendship, forgiveness, dedicated marriage, good conquering evil, choices, redemption, etc, Spiderman III rocked.

So, in sum: Saturday seeking Shakespeare 'n Spiderman equals: a day of language. (Which, unfortunately is a word without "s"s. And "syntax" isn't quite right either. Silliness. Does "language" have an "s" synonym?)